Matt notes that "a problem squared is a problem halved" is only true if the problem is only half a problem to start with.
Matt says "early adapter" when he means "early adopter". But it could be both. It's a podcast that changes you.
I wanna know what the deal with shoe sizes is.
Shoe sizes are a mess. Units are a mess. Matt proposes a system: Measure the foot length and width in mm, rounded to half centimetres. Matt discovers that this system is also called Mondopoint. [Editor's note: The Mondopoint system is standardized by ISO 9407.] Listeners are invited to embroider (or write with permanent marker) their Mondopoint shoe size onto their shoes. Matt promises to send the first listener who sends a picture of an embroidered shoe a signed copy of his book.
A "ting" by Bec
What is the most number of my own organs I can sell for the highest profit without dying in the process?
You can live with only 45% of your own body mass, but don't try this at home. If you sold all those body parts, you could make just over £900'000. You can also sell blood, plasma, hair, sperm, eggs, bone marrow, breast milk, faeces, urine, or be a surrogate mother. Bec's on a list now and her search history is ruined forever. Oh, and she buys human teeth from adult humans for £2 per tooth (£5 or a pint for a wisdom tooth).
None, but Bec says "So that's all the problems solved in this first episode" at the end of the episode, which I consider an implicit ding
Bec says "4" instead of "6". Don't worry: the maths was all ok. Phew.
Bec says "implicit permission" when she means "explicit permission". She will definitely double check before she repurposes any one else's teeth.
Given the general cost of running a fridge is the electricity, and that they're continually becoming more energy efficient whilst electricity becomes more expensive, how often should one buy a new one?
If you've got a fridge from the 90s, you'll make your money back in 3.5 years. If you've got a fridge from the 2000s, it'll take 7 years. Don't even keep the old fridge as a second fridge, buy a new one. But if you buy a new one now, it'll probably last you for a few decades.
A "ka-chiiing" from Bec
Matt needs to buy Christmas presents for his nieces (7 and 9 years old) and needs cool gift ideas.
Idea 1: Harry Potter invisibility cloak (£60), a cape that's green on the inside for use with a green screen.
Idea 2: Scruff A Luvs "My Real Rescue", an electronic toy dog that emulates a rescue dog.
Idea 3: smART pixelator (£50-£70), beads and an app that pixelates images for use as a template.
Idea 4: Oculus Quest (£400-£500), a VR headset. This one might have been from Bec's Christmas list.
Idea 5: LEGO Mars Research Shuttle (£20).
A "That, Bec, is a problem solved" by Matt
Matt and Bec advertise their newly created patreons. It has no perks yet, but they do take mondopoints. It is implied that backer problems might be prioritized.
Alex from Wiltshire embroidered their Mondopoint shoe size onto their shoe, but only the length and not the width, and they spelled Mondopoint wrong. Matt has posted the book, giving Bec no opportunity to sign it.
Matt was Co-Host for Hannah Fry's lectures. He got dressed up as a robot and slimed. Very important: It's Royal Institution, not Royal Institute!
On Christmas Eve, Bec will be on the Jonathan Ross show with a brand new flip chart made specifically for the show. Bec also talks about her life-size cardboard cut-out of David Tennant.
There will be pictures, diagrams, clips, Matt in a robot costume, ...
How much pizza is too much pizza?
Bec decides the standard unit of pizza measurement is a large (14 inch) Domino's Classic Crust Cheese Pizza. It's about 1000 g, which is about 1 l, which is about the volume of the stomach of a non-competitive eater.
Bec asks comedian and doctor Kwame Asante, who notes that you'll die if you consistently eat too much pizza. Bec and Matt decide that the problem is about a single session, and discuss symptoms of overeating.
In 2018, Geoff Esper ate 19.25 9 inch pizzas in 10 minutes, which is almost 8 large pizzas. However, in a twitter poll by Bec, 45% of people say they only eat one pizza.
Given these inconclusive results, Bec and Matt decide on an experimental approach and Bec orders one standard unit of pizza per person. The conclusion: Too much pizza is between 3/4 of a large pizza and one large pizza in a sitting.
A "ding" by Bec
What is the mathematically optimal way to store shirts, in terms of volume used? Folded, rolled, hung up, or some other method?
Matt and Bec practice experimental mathematics with a lot of Matt's nerdy T-shirts and an (initially) empty box. While Bec rolls shirts, Matt explains that his ideal T-shirt storage system should be FIFO (First In, First Out). Bec explains her coat hanger system for tracking worn clothes. Matt debunks the penny pusher T-shirt drawer setup.
Experimental results: The box fits 15 rolled, 12 folded, and 9 scrunched-up T-shirts. While hung-up shirts win for FIFO purposes, rolling is the most volume-efficient.
A "problem solved, ding" by Bec
Matt has never gotten the hang of jet lag. Does Bec have a solution?
Matt is travelling from the UK to the US soon. Both Matt and Bec regularly travel between the UK and Australia. Matt and Bec both originally come from Australia but live in the UK.
Shift-worker syndrome (e.g. from a night shift) is the same thing as jet lag. You can buy melatonin, but it doesn't solve the jet lag itself, just helps getting to sleep. Hangover and jet lag are similar: Not sleeping and hydrating properly.
Bec suggests moistening clothes in the in-flight bathroom. It helps with dehydration, and people won't want to sit near you, which gives you space to sleep. Matt will give it a go on his flight and report back.
Matt and Bec continue plugging their Patreon, which at this point has 17 members. One of those is Michael Hill, Bec's brother. Matt and Bec then thank all 19 of them individually. [Editor's note: Patreon names won't be transcribed because of all the mispronunciation shenanigans in later episodes.]
Bec lost her voice and then had to do three shows. Her voice has not recovered yet. Matt explains that he instead goes mute when he's about to lose his voice, thereby still sort of losing it.
Is 2020 the start of the new decade or the end of the previous decade?
Bec retweeted a thing of the decade, someone else replied and was angry, so Bec roped Matt into it. People on both sides yelled at Matt. Matt and Bec discuss twitter and go on to reinvent 90's forums.
There is no year 0, 1 AD immediately follows 1 BC. This is different from birthdays: When you're n years old, you've been out of the womb for n years (and a bit). When it's the year n though, there have only been n-1 years (and a bit). This means that the first 10 years, i.e. the first decade, starts at the beginning of year 1 and ends at the beginning of year 11. However, decade names like "the 20s" count the years starting at 2020.
Matt goes on a tangent of saying "zero" instead of "oh" in phone numbers. In the book 1984, there's room one-hundred-and-one. James Bond is Agent seven, the lead zeroes are unnecessary.
The International Standards Organization (ISO) released ISO 8601 (eight-six-zero-one), the official standard for dates and times. They ruled that 1 BC is year 0 and 1 AD is year 1. This means our decade started in the year 2020. What pedant can argue against that?
A "ting" by Bec
Now that you've eaten too much pizza, what is the optimal sequence for brushing teeth? Upper before lower? Left before right? Insides before outsides? Working in quadrants? Could electric brushes require different sequences to ordinary brushes? Does the amount of viscosity of the toothpaste play a factor?
The sequence doesn't matter as long as you're brushing them equally. Most tooth-related organizations say you should brush in quadrants, for timing: 30 seconds per quadrant, 2 minutes in total. Matt worked this out on his own from his electric toothbrush, which, by the way, are not faster than manual brushing.
Matt worries that always starting in the same quadrant has a negative effect and instead rotates his starting quadrants. Sources online surprisingly don't mention this, though Bec guesses this has no effect.
You only need a pea-sized amount of tooth paste, more doesn't help. Just make sure it contains fluoride. Also, spit but don't rinse, and don't use mouth wash for at least 30 minutes after brushing. You don't want to remove all the fluoride again that you've just put on your teeth.
A few more tips: Brush your tongue too, lots of bacteria on there. Floss before you brush, so you brush away the dislodged detritus. Wait at least 20 minutes after eating before brushing, because acid in the food softens your enamel.
If you want to speed-run brushing, you can try an Amabrush, a brush that looks like a mouth guard and brushes all your teeth at the same time in 10 seconds. Sadly, it's a kickstarter and they seem to have gone bankrupt. Instead, Matt suggests one electric toothbrush per hand, working on diagonally opposite quadrants at the same time.
Addendum by Bec's friend Sophie (a professional dentist): The starting quadrant does not matter, the toothbrush only removes plaque. Brush your gums as well, plaque likes to accumulates between teeth and gums. Tooth paste saturates the saliva with fluoride, calcium, phosphate; the saliva then washes it over the teeth. This process takes time, so spit, don't rinse, wait 30 minutes. One of the manual brush techniques mentioned was called the "bass" technique. If you must use mouthwash, use it before brushing.
A "ting" by Bec
The premise of Bec's show "Out of Order" is that the jokes are on 25 post-its on a board and the audience gets to pick the order. What is the maximum amount of times Bec can do this show before she hits the same order again?
There are 15'511'210'043'330'985'984'000'000 (15.5 septillion) distinct orders: At the beginning, there's 25 options for the first joke, then 24 for the second, and so on, which makes 25*24*...*1 = 25! ("25 factorial") joke orders. If the audience chooses at random, you have to do roughly 500 billion shows before you hit the first repeat order (on average). Matt requests Bec to log the order of each of her 25 or more shows, so they can analyze the results afterwards.
A "ding" by Bec
Did Matt try Bec's solution to soak the clothes in water? No, he drank the water instead. Staying very hydrated seems to have helped though.
A "So you did, you solved the problem" by Matt
Matt recommends electrical tape, to tape over bright LEDs in hotel rooms. Bec recommends using your own slippers from home, it makes the place feel more comfortable and like home. Matt's mother has knitted him socks that look like shoes. He uses them on walking holidays when walking around in hotels, because carrying normal shoes means extra weight.
The patreon has gained 16 supporters, and now has 31 in total. This makes 31% towards their first goal of 100 supporters.
On the way back from Brussels ComicCon, Bec got really ill with all the Coronavirus symptoms (only a flu though). She was quarantining before it was cool. Matt surprisingly didn't want to have her over for a podcast recording. They decided to make this episode the Quarantine Special.
What happens if you actually get quarantined in a hospital? What do you take? What goes on? Any recommendations?
There's not much, only a bed, bathroom, sink, and a window (nature's TV). Chances are you're so sick you don't need anything else. Don't worry too much about entertainment. Take a tooth brush, tooth paste, toiletries (if you have preferred ones). Take a couple of pairs of socks and a spare blanket. Take a pair of normal clothes for your way home. Maybe a friend who can drive you back and then leave the car for two weeks.
They gave her a phlegm flask to collect samples from violent coughing. Take some fun item to put in there, maybe a lego figurine, dnd miniature, a small vial of Worcestershire sauce, or wasabi. When hospitals are overloaded, all the staff want is a little laugh (at least according to Matt).
"[…] while the virus is still alive." — Bec
A "ding" from Bec
What are Matt and Bec's tips for working from home?
Keep in touch with other people, but don't over-socialize too fast. Maintain a certain routine. Bec is recording this episode from a small closet under her neighbour's stairs, by the way.
Bec's routine: Bec has a big whiteboard with a check list which she has to complete every day. First, she writes a few pages stream-of-consciousness, for mental health purposes. She has a stay-focused app that blocks messages before 10:00 and after 22:00. One of the items is "go outside".
Matt's routine: Matt refuses to look at the emails before he officially starts work. After Matt and Lucie get ready, they walk to work by walking around the block once (a 20 minute walk). At the end of the day, they walk the other way back around the block.
Bec challenges people to recreate the dance from Iceland's Eurovision entry "Think about things" to get exercise instead of going for a walk at the same time as everybody else. Matt will not participate.
Matt's tip for getting up at a reasonable time: Have a proper schedule that doesn't make you get to bed late. Bec's advice for staying focused: Don't talk to her. Create a dedicated work space or corner. Bec has a working nook in her kitchen. Listeners are encouraged to send pictures of their own workspaces.
A "ding" from Matt
Bec has been seeing a lot of memes and infographics, and she doesn't know which ones to believe. Bec describes a specific meme titled "The power of social distancing" that shows significant decrease in infections when exposure is reduced.
Matt looked up the source of the meme, which appears to be reputable. He then reverse-engineered their calculations, which appear to be sensible. Some infographics count the currently infected cases, some (like this one) counts the total amount of infections.
Two things are scary about exponential growth: First, a slight difference in the infection rate has a large effect on the end result. Second, it starts deceptively slow but in the end grows very large very quickly. As an example, Matt fills all the houses in the UK with rice in one month.
A "ding" by Bec
Manic responds "I'm amazed at how thoroughly you answered my problem. Especially with Bec going above and beyond in roping in a dentist friend."
By Manic
When episode 003 was released, a lot of listeners replied they couldn't hear Bec, or she was very quiet, or she felt very far away. Some said she was phoning in from the ISS.
Producer John Harvey explains that Bec's waveform was out of phase and had to be flipped. Flipping a sound wave just inverts the wave form. Adding opposite sound waves cancels them out. This is the idea behind noise cancelling headphones, and can also be used to remove vocals from songs.
Using the phase of the audio and weird combinations of the channels, an approximation of surround sound can be encoded in stereo channels. This is called Matrix Decoding.
A link to the broken episode can be found in the show notes. Listeners are encouraged to play it on a variety of weird devices. Bec also provides a weird audio file that has caused problems with some venue audio setups.
A "ding" by John
If you're on a crowded tube train with a backpack, where is the best place to put it? On the floor, people assume it's a space to stand in. In my hand, it lurches into people. How can I get in people's way the least?
Bec likes big backpacks and cannot lie them on the ground in the tube.
Solution 1: There need to be dedicated backpack carriages for backpackers where half of people are really tall and the other half is short. Alternatively, put some people in upside-down like Tetris.
Solution 2: Wear the backpack on your front, put your clothes over it, and wear a "baby on board" badge. People will stay clear of your bag and you might even get a seat.
Bridget gets to decide whether this solves the problem.
As an air traffic controller, I am bound by certain restrictions for safety: 5 nautical miles laterally, and 1000 ft. Which, let's be honest, is a lot of room. Go out and run 5 miles. That's how close I'm allowed to have two aircraft at the same altitude. That's a ton of space, right? I could easily fit more in there. But then I wondered: How much more? So my question is: In a 3-dimensional space with a radius of 5 nm and 1000 ft high, just how many airplanes could I cram in there and have none of them touching? Not travelling per se, but a frozen snapshot in time, assuming each aircraft is a Boeing 737, for sake of measurement ease. Thanks!
Matt commends the level of precision and detail in the question. However, Matt did not run the 5 miles. The described volume is a cylinder. While one might think the cylinder would be 2000 ft high, the question was very clear about its height.
Matt builds an aircraft cake with 24 layers and 177'987 planes per layer, for a total of just over 4.2 million planes. If you interlace the wings, you can fit approximately 6'334'728 planes instead. This is a packing problem, which are notoriously difficult. You might fit even more by computer simulation. Nowhere in the question does Rob state the aircraft needs to be intact, so you could fit even more by compressing them.
However, the aircraft has only been ordered 15'115 times, of which 10'575 have been delivered. So the actual answer is just: All of them.
A "ding" by Bec
In my house, Matt has a spare guest bedroom. What has to happen to make that the perfect guest bedroom for people who stay over? Current inventory. Bedside table with a lamp, USB power outlets built into the wall socket. And a bed.
Suggestion 1: Get rid of them boxes.
Suggestion 2: If you expect people to stay for a few nights (which is not the case here), a space to hang and put clothes.
Listeners' favourite things in their bedrooms: A bed and comfortable mattress (which is already in place). A (cuddly) toy or figurine, possibly puzzles. A quilt. A partner (Lucy?). A pet (including kids; befriend/steal neighbour's cat). A Spider That Lives In The Room And Catches Flies. A Star Wars pillow case. A butt (by Picasso). A Bec shrine (or for the specific guest).
Bec provides Matt with a futuristic garden. It's a toy, but has live, so it's a pet, and it's space-related, so it's related to Matt's partner.
A "ding" by Bec
Matt assumed Bec lived in a 10 m by 10 m by 10 m void (1000 m³). Bec measured her flat, which is 8 m by 6 m by 2.3 m (110 m³). Matt was off by an order of magnitude, which means a factor of 10. As an example, 3 orders of magnitude is a 1000 times difference. Matt's error means Bec's house would've been full of rice two days sooner.
Bec's coping quite well, but her fitbit keeps telling her off for not walking enough. Following government advice, Matt and Lucie have now opened a pub in their backyard.
Bec has found an old white T-shirt that she wants to divide into 500 regions. People can pay £10 for her to draw or write something in one space. How should she arrange the 500 regions on the shirt?
Old Man Matt reminisces about the Million Dollar Website. Since Matt didn't answer in time because he didn't have an off-the shelf cauldron ready, Bec also asked her little brother Mike. Mike computed that each section should be about 4 cm by 4 cm in size. However, he did not figure out how to arrange them, which Matt did.
Matt wrote some Python code and checked 5'904 different square arrangements (not including sleeves). Optimizing for area, the best solution is a lot of very thin regions. With some manual sorting, Matt's favourite solution was: 3cm wide by 2.1cm tall, on the front 20 wide by 23 tall, on the back 10 wide by 27 tall.
Bec changed the shirt size, which Matt accounted for in his code. The code is taking quite a while though, so they decide to do another problem first.
What portion of the energy that goes into a clothes dryer ends up trapped as static electricity on the clothing?
It takes about as much energy to run a clothes dryer for an hour as does running a human for a day. According to regulations, the maximum percentage of that energy that may be static charge is 0.00000324%.
The code from problem 006-1 is still running.
A "ding" by Bec
What do the numbers on a toaster mean? Is it minutes? Would setting your toaster to 5 burn your house down? What happens if you set your toaster to 1 but a few seconds later you change it to 3? Does it let you change it? What happens if you set a toaster to 5 but you wait until it's around about the 3 level of cooked and then turn it down to 1? What would happen? What if you have a four-slice toaster with two levers but one dial, and you set the dial to a 3 and push down the first lever, and then halfway through you push down the second lever?
Bec checked a video by Tom Scott (recommended by Matt) who tested what the numbers on toasters mean. She then reached out via Twitter and @press_coffee and @regularlods [Editor's note: I could not find the second account, and might have misheard the name] who helped with experiments with their own toasters.
What do the numbers on a toaster mean? Is it minutes? The numbers don't mean minutes, and it's not even a linear scale.
Would setting your toaster to 5 burn your house down? Depends on your toaster (the podcast doesn't have insurance to find out an actual answer).
What happens if you set your toaster to 1 but a few seconds later you change it to 3? Does it let you change it? Experiments verify that different toasters do different things.
What happens if you set a toaster to 5 but you wait until it's around about the 3 level of cooked and then turn it down to 1? What would happen? In every case, the toast popped up.
What if you have a four-slice toaster with two levers but one dial, and you set the dial to a 3 and push down the first lever, and then halfway through you push down the second lever? Limmy replied they have a four-slice toaster, but they'd prefer the mystery and don't want to know. If anybody works out the answer: Don't tell Limmy! Instead, say: "I watch Limmy's show thanks to A Problem Squared, and really enjoyed it."
The code is done! 3cm by 3cm squares, one 11 by 20 block and one 14 by 20 block (one on the front and one on the back). Bec will take the average of Matt's and Mike's solutions and do 3.5 cm by 3.5 cm squares.
@McKGerald on twitter thinks Matt is right about the surround sound encoding: Bec sounded like she was behind them. Bec's mate Ron from Northern Ireland reckons he can fix Bec's audio file.
Bec and Matt received a tweet containing only a solitary ding.
By Bridget B
Matt and Bec thank 46 patreon supporters. They will do a full credit thanks next episode.
The new theme was created by Howard Carter, who also composed the standupmaths and Festival of the Spoken Nerd theme tunes.
What is the biggest thing in Australia based on scale? In other words, what is the biggest in comparison to what the normal thing should be? What is the funniest if you're going solely on "unexpectedly big" on scale?
First, Bec and Matt ramble a long time about unusually sized objects, including a pair of children's size roller skates and a reference to problem 001-1.
Matt found 249 big things in Australia. The most common big thing is apples, the biggest of which is about 5 m tall. Things that are smaller than they should be are the Big (map of) Australia and the Big Ayers Rock.
Contenders for the answer are the Big Ant, the Big Macadamia Nut, the Big Olive, and the Big Redback Spider. They're all about the same scale factor, within rounding and guessing errors. Bec chooses the Big Macadamia Nut, which is in proximity to a Big Pineapple. Listeners are encouraged to send pictures of themselves with a big thing.
A "ding" by Bec
Person 1 asked: If you're an average person, could you win the lottery and retire, or is there not enough money? Person 2 asked: How much do I need to save for retirement? I know what financial people say, what do maths people say?
Matt combines the questions into "If you won a million dollars, would that be enough for retirement?" and interpreted "retirement" as "30 years". That makes $33'000 per year. With inflation, that will be roughly $11'000 after 30 years, so you need some sort of investment that matches inflation.
Legally, Matt can't give financial advice, but he had a look at stamps: In the UK, some stamps don't have a value on them, but their price increases occasionally and they don't expire. The stock market gives a better return on average but is also a lot more dangerous. You could also buy an annuity and not rely on the postal service continuing to exist. Some lotteries also offer an annuity as a reward.
So maths people say "listen to the financial people" and Bec says "give it to me".
A legally distinct "dong" by Bec
Requests have started to come in. The money is going to WaterAid.
Bec's favourite ones: "Draw whatever you miss most about Melbourne" (Shanghai Dumpling House sign). "Draw whatever squiggle you prefer" (a picture of Mr. Squiggle). "Do a drawing of a cock and balls" (a rooster with some sports balls). "A goose honking" (a goose holding a horn and honking it).
She hated "Samurai Senior Snails", but the person at least bought four squares. UK Bricks and Unison West Berkshire bought advertisement squares. Danq.me bought six squares, one per letter. Bec's mum bought four squares ("Every life is a story, every story is a book"). Matt bought 8 squares in a T shape for Bec to draw a 1/7th scale picture of the T-shirt itself.
People have filled out the online form from last episode. There appears to be no pattern. Bec criticises the question order. They discuss the chaos that are the responses. Bec wishes she hadn't embarked on this journey. Instead of drawing conclusions from the mess of data, Bec drew congratulations and thanks for each person who helped with the problem.
Deemed "too ridiculous to solve" by Matt
The patreon has been slightly overhauled: Everyone has early access, and there is an "I'm a wizard" level now. Matt and Bec thank 33 patreon supporters.
Bec has started doing yoga lessons given by her friend and comedian Abigoliah on instagram. The next lesson sets a very hard deadline for this podcast recording.
Lucie and Matt celebrated 100 consecutive day at home together, which is a personal best for their relationship. Matt cooked a "100 consecutive days at home together" dinner in celebration: Two pizzas and one stick of garlic bread to form the shape of 100. Bec would've built a phallic shape with them instead. Matt now needs something in the shape of a 2 for the 200 days anniversary; Bec suggests a garlic swan.
My brother keeps complaining about a situation he and his wife are in. Namely, he's pretty tall and she's definitely short, and neither of them like using the kitchen counters because the average height that they are designed for is uncomfortable to reach down to or reach up to respectively. How can I get him to stop complaining to me about this problem or — even better — what could they do to solve their kitchen height woes?
Bec suffers from an optical illusion where people assume her to be smaller than she actually is, and her husband Gavin is very tall, so she can emphasize. Her solution: Her husband does all the cooking.
For a more practical solution: Bec asked her friend and comedian Gareth Berliner, who is married to Kiruna Stamell who has dwarfism. He mentioned rise and fall counters, which are counterweighted and can change their height. Bec contacted Ed Warner, whose company called Motionspot makes well-designed accessible counters. He explains the different types of furniture they offer.
To stop the complaining, Manic should get their brother to listen to this episode (as should people with similar problems).
A "I think I can confidently give that a very firm ding" by Matt
My question is truly global: I'm wondering whether the recorded area of each country — as stated by encyclopedias etc. — assumes the country is completely flat/completely smooth, i.e part of the surface of a sphere, or takes into account topography. For some countries, e.g. the Netherlands, there might be little difference between these figures. But for others, e.g. Switzerland or Norway, the many steep mountains could surely make a significant difference. Any idea which country would exhibit the biggest difference, and whether it would be enough to change its place in the traditional ranking of countries by land area. Thanks!
Matt likes the problem; Bec wonders if Phil has land investments. For tides at coasts, you use the mean high water mark as a defined border. Matt explains the coastline paradox, where a coastline is fractal and its length changes depending on the granularity in which you measure it.
Matt could not find out who's in charge of the UK's surface area, so he looked at Australia (which is about 31 UKs in size), for which Geoscience Australia is responsible. Matt struggles with their geo data format. Geoscience Australia confirms that they don't include height in their computations. Matt extrapolates that this applies to all countries.
Alistair Ray [Editor's note: Spelling likely incorrect] has previously tried to answer this question using a 25 km² chunk of Scotland. However, the same coastline problem now applies to the 2D surface of the land: The higher the resolution of your data, the higher the surface area. The 25 km² area in Scotland increased by 7.1% to 8%. Switzerland increased by 6.96%, Liechtenstein increased by 8.72%.
Matt will keep working on this problem and plans to release a YouTube video on the standupmaths channel at the same time the podcast is released. Bec only gives it a "di", the "ng" will be awarded when the video is released
Problem: Why don't plastic things dry in the dishwasher? Why? Whyyyyyyyyyy?
Bec has no (electric) dishwasher; Matt is a big fan of them. Matt experimented with his dishwasher earlier before recording, which opens itself slightly once it's finished. He guesses it has to do with the heat capacity of the materials (i.e. how easily they warm up or cool down). Matt suspects that Plastic has a lower capacity, thus cools down quick and doesn't dry well, while ceramics retain heat longer. Lucie suspects surfactants in the detergent, which change how the water interacts, beads, and drains off. Bec suspects plastic containers are usually containers, which would trap steam better. Their theories run into more and more troubles with differently-shaped and -materialed kitchen implements. Listeners are encouraged to do their own experiments and report back. Dish washing experts are also encouraged to get in contact.
Colin Jamine [Editor's note: Spelling likely incorrect] sent in photographs of themselves with many big things, though not with the Big Macadamia Nut. Pictures have also come in via Twitter, again not with the Big Macadamia Nut.
We're on the back of the shirt now, over halfway! Bec has underestimated the amount of effort required. Bec has bought a proper set of fabric markers with Ko-fi money, which means the back will look better. Matt encourages others to commission scaled copies of the back of the T-shirt for the back of the T-shirt.
Bec noted that they did not mention James Bond in the last episode, episode 007, after talking about the pronunciation of 007 in 003-1. A listener mentioned that in the books, they use the letter O instead of the number 0 for typesetting, meaning the pronunciation "double-o seven" is the correct one, not Matt's "zero zero seven". Matt is genuinely upset: "It's a license to kill, it's not a license to mess with numbering systems!"
Bec has been announced as the ambassador for the UK Crafts Council. She does this only so she can go to those parties with Ferrero Rocher pyramids. Matt is distracted by pyramid stacking maths.
Matt won the Christopher Zeeman medal for maths communication. With Bec's Best Kid's Show at Leicester Comedy Festival 2019 award, this makes A Problem Squared an award-winning podcast.
Andrew retweeted a tweet by @dumbbass: "We need to melt down all the pennies and make the Statue of Liberty a girlfriend." Andrew then asked: Would the resulting girlfriend be far too big, far too small, or sort of about right?
Matt agrees that the penny should be abolished, and would strategically pay with cash or card so the rounding would be in his favour.
There's currently 130 billion pennies in circulation in the US. Using only their copper, you could make 81.25 statue of liberty sized girlfriends, or one girlfriend that's 9 times as big. The zinc from the coins is not a structural material.
Matt recommends that, after pennies are abolished, the next year's worth of materials should be turned into a statue. This statue would be within 10% of the Statue of Liberty.
A "ding" by Bec
Yo, I love burgers, but people keep making 'em too tall and I can't fit them in my mouth. Question: For a standard human jaw, what is the upper limit of burger height such that you can bite through top to bottom in one chomp?
The average human jaw can open roughly three human fingers wide. If you can't fit more than two and you go for surgery, you need to let your surgeon know. So your burger should be at most three fingers high, or two if you want to be careful.
To experimentally verify her results, Bec spent all of Saturday ordering five of the tallest burgers she could find. A video is available on her YouTube channel. The biggest burger was 10 cm high compared to Bec's 5 cm high mouth, and even with her special burger hooking technique, she did not manage to get a bite. Meat burgers can be compressed to approximately 80% their original size.
Matt dislikes tall burgers: Your burger should not need a load-bearing skewer to stay in place. Also, making your burger wider is a more efficient way to gain volume. Matt also accepts cutting a burger in half like a sandwich, but Bec vehemently disagrees.
The twitter account seems to have only ever asked this one question, and was later suspended for violation of twitter's rules.
Matt did not get the video done in time for the last episode's release, but it's coming along. Matt kept learning more and more stuff, and the scale of the video kept growing. Matt promises that the video will be released in time with this podcast for real.
Matt can confirm that the UK does not include terrain when computing the area, thanks to Dr. Laura Graham of the University of Birmingham. Matt can confirm that Switzerland will overtake the Netherlands in the ranking of area when you include its terrain. For small countries like the UK, the curvature of the earth is negligible. For large countries like Australia, they use an area-preserving projection.
The production quality of the video kept increasing. Matt bought a drone, got Paul and Dr. Graham to record their questions and answers, and Bec played the voice of Geoscience Australia. They do an impromptu recording of Geoscience Australia's response for the video.
Bec still gives the problem only a "di".
The goal after one year of podcasting was 100 patreon supporters. After 9 months, there are 56 patreon supporters. Thus, more patreon advertisement. Though of course nobody should feel pressured to pay on patreon.
Bec went to Scotland for her mother-in-law's 80th birthday. She took her Oculus Quest to show her mother-in-law a safari thing. Then, she showed her niece Richie's Plank Experience and made her cry.
Matt finally published his video, after missing his self-imposed deadlines twice. Bec compliments the voice actor for the Geosicence Australia voice. Afterwards, he released a video on mega-favourite numbers.
Keeping cool in the non-air-conditioned home office: When opening a window seems to let more heat in than cooling breezes, what's the best way to keep cool whilst working at home?
Advice 1: On hot days, keep your curtains closed.
Advice 2: Buy a fan or an air conditioner. If you only have a fan, point it blowing over a bowl of ice, or drape a wet towel over yourself and sit in front of a fan.
Advice 3: Cover yourself in minty shower gel.
A "ding" from Bec
Tristan made a detour and visited the Big Macadamia Nut from problem 007-1. He'd like to know what the value of the Big Macadamia Nut would be, monetarily, if it was an actual nut.
The nut may be 640 times bigger than a normal one, but if you wanted to fill it, you'd need 242'144'000 normal sized nuts because the volume grows with the cube of the size. Those would be worth 11'796'480 AUD, or roughly 12 million AUD, or £6.5 million, or $8.5 million, or 7 million €. You'd have 865 tons of edible nut bits. Awaiting a reply from Tristan.
Hey Bec and Matt - I'm moving into a new house soon and I have this problem that I need solving. This house has one additional room that I don't need (an entirely new issue for someone who has lived in high cost of living cities - Sydney and London - for their whole life). What should I do with this spare room?
Bec's suggestions: Turn it into a secret room with a disguised door, for all your secrets. Also, get a Murphy bed (fold-down bed) for the room, so it can be used as an emergency guest room and Matt and Bec can visit. Bec goes on a diversion on animal crossing pocket camp. She suggests Mike to get a hobby and fill the room with related items, or to find a person that needs a room and give it to them. Awaiting a reply from Matt. Listeners are encouraged to send pictures of their own secret rooms.
After talking about Bond in problem 003-1 and episode 008 (note), another listener pointed out that type writers used to have no zero, meaning you had to write Os instead. Matt has two type writers, both of which have both a zero and an o key. Neither has a one key, and you are supposed to use the lowercase l. He also once took a type writer to a lecture.
The keyboard in the first commercial typewriter patent (by the person who invented the QWERTY keyboard) has neither a one nor a zero. It also has no exclamation mark; instead, you put an apostrophe over the full stop. Bec and Matt think about other keys that could be removed. There's also a three-vertical-dots mystery key.
After previously talking about stacking Ferrero Rochers, Bec wanted to know how many Ferrero's were in the pile. Matt insists that it should be a square pyramid, but it's actually a cone shape. Matt is not done with this problem.
The patreon subscribers are increasing. If they increase in a linear fashion, the podcast will hit its goal from episode 003 (note).
Matt and friends have started A Podcast of Unnecessary Detail. Of course, you can also listen to one of Bec's 69 million other podcasts.
Matt and Lucie use a different account to watch videos than to create videos, and YouTube suggests Matt to said account. Matt, however, doesn't like to watch his own videos, making its statistics slightly works. Matt and Bec discuss thumbnail clicking statistics.
Bec did the Jonathan Ross Comedy Club recording, which will come out in a couple of days right after Britain's Got Talent. Matt explains that this is a big deal.
Correction from the show notes: Bec's episode of Jonathan Ross's Comedy Club aired on 10th September (Series 1 Episode 2).
Matt got a shoutout from the Seth Myers show, after a video he made about the quality of talkshow hosts filming from home. Colbert didn't reply, but Seth thanked Matt for the tips and Matt continued assisting Seth. Bec was frustrated that he mention this earlier.
Since episode 1 is when the podcast starts, is this an n-out-of-n+1 thing as 12 months ends at the 13th episode as there is a month between each episode?
Does the goal of 100 patrons after one year from episode 003 (note) apply in episode 012 or 013? Matt counts the month leading up to an episode as the month of the episode (the producers' perspective), while Bec counts the month after the episode (the audience's perspective). Taking both perspectives into account, there's 13 months in a year. Matt proposes a linear fade-in during the preceding month and a linear fade-out during the succeeding month, keeping the total amount at 1 the entire time. Awaiting ding from author.
Previously, Bec and Matt talked about a Ferrero Rocher pyramid from a classic commercial. How many Ferrero Rochers do you require to assemble a platter of the proportions as seen in the commercial?
@setalyas on Twitter used a circle-packing website to work out the amount of Ferrero Rochers. Packing smaller circles into a big circle is a really hard problem. Matt bought almost hundreds of Ferrero Rochers with his Seth Myers consultancy money to verify the results experimentally. After a lot of trial and error, Matt has successfully stacked the balls, though he has not counted them. Matt promises to lend Bec his sweets after counting, so she can have a go (and definitely not just eat them all).
"The outer layers are a manifestation of what's going on inside" — Matt Parker, 2020
Follow-up problem: Is 216 chocolates spoiling the people? Bec used her new ambassador powers to guess that there are about 200 people. Matt notes that having exactly as many sweets as guests is top-tier ambassadoring. Bec suggests that only one sweet per person is spoiling their fun.
Matt calculates that the maximum number of Ferrero Rochers in a pile before it collapses under its own weight, based on his own measurements, is 68'814'850 Ferrero Rochers in 650 layers, costing just over £26.25 million.
How do we determine when an area changes name based on volume? At what point does a room become a great room? At what point does a great room become a ballroom? When does a ballroom become a great hall? And in the other direction: What about a hallway? At what point does a hallway become a room? And when does a closet become a room? Is it number of doors?
Number one: What makes a room a room is whether it can fit the thing that the room is named after. A closet can't fit a bed, so it's not a bedroom.
Number two: The word "hallway" comes from "hall", which was a large building. It is also a room, but with lots of doorways to other rooms going off it. Its name doesn't change based on its volume.
Number three: A room becomes a great room when Bec Hill is in there.
A "problem solved, ding, bye" from Bec
The T-shirt is finished and Bec wore it on the Jonathan Ross Comedy Club. She will post info about the money going to WaterAid on her socials.
The number of patreon supporters at the time of recording is 97. It seems likely that the goal from episode 003 (note) will be met, regardless of how a year of episodes is counted.
Matt still frequents the Step And Conquer, though it has been converted into winter mode. He has also installed a fire pit (the barbecue with its legs taken off), which broke his fire pit cycle. Bec is invited to burn her evidence in Matt's fire pit.
Bec has a new pet: A really cute little hamster named Pudding. She has put a tiny easel with a tiny notepad in his enclosure so he looks like he's doing a tiny flipchart gig.
Bec proposes the format "A Pudding Squared" where simple hamster problems for children are posed. This episode: Hamsters in the wild can run up to 9 km. Pudding's little wheel is 14 cm in diameter. How many rotations does Pudding have to run to get the same exercise as he would get in the wild?
Sharks constantly grow new teeth. What is the fastest rate you can pull their teeth out so that they always have at least one tooth (assuming one tooth at a time)?
Bec likes this problem because of her obsession with teeth, described in problem 001-2. Shark have a conveyor belt of teeth in their mouth. Nobody really knows how many teeth shark have, or how fast they regrow. Bec's best guess is anywhere between a day and a few weeks. She that sharks have roughly 49 teeth in their outer layer, and that each tooth is replaced once a week, which makes a tooth every three or so hours, or every hour during working hours (including weekends), but you take lunch time off.
A "ding" by Bec
I have a question: A lot of people are infected with covid, but a virus is also very small. That made me wonder: How many litres of the virus are there? I guess it can't be that much.
A cell is about 10'000 times smaller than a human. Bacteria are about 1000 time smaller than our cells. A virus is around 1000 times smaller than bacteria. Matt estimates one virus to be 150 nm across. Scientists estimate 400'000 viruses per ml of fluid. Matt estimates 2 l of said fluid per infected person, 300'000 new cases per day, and an average infection length of 2 weeks, meaning there's just over 4'000'000 people currently infected.
Combining all that gives us roughly 3.3 quadrillion (3.3e15) virus cells. Stacking them like tiny Ferrero Rochers (see problem 011-2), this gives us roughly 8 ml of virus, about a teaspoon. No matter how you tweak the numbers, it'll fit into a shot glass.
Footnote: Even though virus particles are tiny, it's still worth wearing a mask. The viruses in the air are carried by substantially bigger droplets.
An "I'm happy with saying that's definitely a problem solved" from Bec
I used to think of big fluffy jackets as being inherently warm, but of course they're really just insulation against the cold. How hot does it have to be outside before wearing a jacket will help you stay cool? Does it depend on how long one spends in the heat?
Our core body temperature is around 37°C, Bec's slightly cooler 🕶️. Naïve answer: At any temperature above 37°C, the jacket insulates us against the outside heat. But biology is a lot more complicated. The body constantly generates heat, and the jacket will prevent sweating.
Bec was confused by firefighters and their calendars, so she asked Dr. Rohan Francis, who then asked a firefighter. The jackets allow the firefighters to walk through flames, but only for a certain amount of time.
Bec has access to both a fluffy jacket and an infrared sauna for experiments, but she is not sure how to experiment. She asks listeners to contact her with ideas.
I recently bought Cheese in Tesco's in a more unconventional shape. Tesco claims that this squarer packaging uses 40% less packaging than its previous rectangular block. [The author forgot to measure an old block of cheese for comparison, but includes measurements for the new block.] Firstly, is Tesco correct in saying there's a 40% reduction in plastic? What would be the most efficient packing solution that minimizes wasted space and cuts down on plastic? Which products would have the greatest improvement in reducing packaging by just changing its shape?
Matt does not think there is a sensible shape for the old packet that would lead to a 41% reduction in surface area. The only real option would be a large thin pancake of cheese, which seems unrealistic. There must be something else going on.
The best way to package would be a cheese ball 9 cm across. A sphere has the smallest surface area of all shapes. However, wrapping and stacking them becomes worse (as discussed in problem 011-2). So instead, Matt wants a shape that stacks well but minimizes surface area, which is known as the Kelvin problem. Lord Kelvin claimed in 1887 that a truncated octahedron was the optimal shape. In 1993, he was proved wrong with a weirder shape.
But for transport in a cuboid box, you want a cuboid shape, so Tesco's approach is actually the right one. Matt suspects that optimizing the shape for transport might be a bigger deal than the actual amount of plastic, but that's hard to describe on a block of cheese.
Matt Bec suggests contacting Tesco's. wants to measure some cheese. Listeners are encouraged to ask Tesco's as well. Bec suggests the hashtag #cheesecoverup.
Matt wants to send out christmas cards for patreon supporters of the podcast, but he doesn't know what to put on them.
Matt has sent math-pun-ish christmas cards to his patreon supporters for the past four years, which he shows Bec. Since the podcast patreon goal (from episode 003 (note)) was met, he also wants to start the same tradition for this podcast. He requests help from Bec for christmas card ideas. The new patreon goal for the next year of APS will be 314 patrons, or roughly pi hundred.
A lot of problems are maths based, which is great but Bec's specialty is more creativity-based. Bec wants more of those. Don't stop sending in the maths problems though!
Listeners are encouraged to fill in the survey linked in the episode description, so Matt and Bec get some good feedback for the show.
Bec has filmed a block of Makeaway Takeaway. The kids were trying to stay away from her (social distancing).
Both the Daily Mirror and the Daily Mail turned the answer to the problem into a news story, as if it was a big new finding. Matt got the option to use the excuse "Sorry, I'm late to this meeting, the Daily Mirror unexpectedly wrote a story about me."
I'm living by myself three floors up without an elevator, and I often find really nice furniture outside that I can't take because I can't carry them up the stairs by myself. Is there a most efficient way of carrying something big and heavy upstairs in terms of how much energy one has to put into it?
Matt's Step And Conquer gazebo from problem 004-2 was damaged in a storm, but he found another identical gazebo being thrown out at the same time and used it for parts.
Matt calculates that the weight of the object decreases very slightly as you go up higher. Bec suggests to flood the stairway and utilize buoyancy. Matt suggests an online calculator for how many helium balloons you need to hover an object. Matt also suggests a pulley system, but is not responsible for any damages caused.
Bec has five suggestions for getting someone else to do it: Dress like a little old lady nun and look like you're struggling, convince some passing children that it's a game, design a fake VR game about moving furniture and call for beta testers, get an ACME catapult or trebuchet, or leave it in the street for Bec's mum to trip over, and she'll put it away.
Bec also veers dangerously close to practical advice with a sack trolley with three wheels that are optimized for stairs. She contacted Luka Muller from the "Oooh, Spooky" podcast who is a professional removalist, who recommends a manoeuvre called the "lover's shelf" or the "mover's g-spot" where you rest the edge of an object in your hip groove (mons pubis). You'll look like you're humping your furniture though.
A "ding" from Bec
"He has a weak constitution" says their birthday is coming up and asks: I don't want anything. People insist on getting me something. What do I ask for? It must be a physical item.
Joanna Williams asks: With christmas looming, I want to do some nice stuff with my boyfriend and for my family, but I don't have a lot of disposable income [Matt: and with the second lockdown, we're obviously limited in what we can do].
Call their bluff and request something hand-made, or hand-make something for your giftees.
Bec suggests a recipe for fudge, full recipe in show notes. Matt mentions a custom spice mix and honey from hobby beekeeping. Bec suggests salt dough, which is basically custom Play-Doh that you bake to make solid. Matt makes candles from other candles' wax. Bec suggests a treasure hunt advent calendar with 25 clues. Listeners are encouraged to share more ideas on instagram.
Another option: Ask for a physical item that helps other people. For example, a product from a company that donates a part of their proceeds.
A "ding" by Matt
Very serious responses from social media managers have come in, though they haven't been very conclusive. The OPP (Original Problem Poser) Adam Light [Editor's note: Spelling likely incorrect] found another cheese that claims the same reduction, which led them to a press release from a packaging company called Ornua. They claim to have reduced the plastic in cheese packaging with something called the "megablock". In addition to changing the shape, they seem to have removed the zip-lock feature. Matt disapproves of this choice. Matt will try to follow-up with the company or marketing director. Bec suspects Adam to be an industry insider and whistleblower.
A bunch of answers have come in. The most common answer was roughly 2454, but that was not the most correct answer. Only Dexter (aged 7 269/366) did a classic Dexter, sent in their working out and came up with the correct answer of 2462.78. Other people, don't mix rounding and precision! Bec gives this answer a "Pud-ding".
The podcast is receiving a lot more problems. Last episode's call for problems was successful.
The listener survey from last episode is still going. There will be a wrap-up with some of the answers in the end-of-year episode.
There were many great suggestions, but then lockdown 2 started and Bec can't do the experiment. The problem is on hold for now.
Bec shows Matt her idea live on the podcast. Matt loves it. It references several problems and has a christmas-themed maths pun. To get a copy, you need to be a patreon supporter. Wizard-level supporters will get a physical card.
Bec and a few listeners have noticed that some problems were not properly closed. She wants a Wikipedia page. Matt doesn't want to miss the 100th ding. Next episode, Bec and Matt will try to ding all undinged problems (as well as look at the survey results).
Inspired by Matthew Scroggs playing Mario on his Christmas tree, Matt has programmed the LED strips on his own Christmas tree. He's photographed them from multiple angles so he can address them by their 3D positions. A few notes on motivation and telling other people about projects follow. Matt promises to publish a Christmas tree video before the next episode. He invites people to write guest code for his tree.
Bec went up to Manchester and got to do a recording of 8 Out of 10 Cats does Comedy Countdown. Matt is very envious of her. Bec was in Dictionary Corner so she did not have to do any maths; instead she drew pictures. The show will come out around Valentine's Day.
Matt got to the bottom of this by going straight to the top: He had a phone call with the Head of Packaging at Tesco, James Bull.
Matt and Bec were correct that the cheese dimensions alone are not enough to explain the plastic savings. There are two more factors. First: By changing the dimensions, they reduced the maximum diagonal, making the package more resistant and reducing the thickness of the plastic. Second: They got rid of the re-sealable part of the packaging, annoying Matt. However, they only did this because they found out that a lot of people were not using the resealable part. There was also some discussion on the advantages and disadvantages of plastic as a material. Then they talked about shelf sizes.
Matt also asked for the exact percentage of improvement that they gave their legal department. They weighed the old packaging (5.8 g) and the new packaging (3.4 g), rounded to the nearest whole gram, and got a reduction of 41.4%.
"We've blown the resealable lid right off this." — Matt
A "Ding, dingalingaling" from Bec
Matt has collated all of the approx. 200 responses for an end-of-year review.
Favourite problem? The first place was 008-2, while 002-1 and 011-2 were also strong. 009-2 also wasn't too bad. While it was not very high on the list (5%), 003-2 changed many people's life. 005-3 was surprisingly high (7%) even though Matt had totally forgot about it.
What do people do while listening? A lot of people are moving (running, driving), but they're doing a whole range of things.
What country? UK (26.9%), USA (21%), a bunch of countries with only a single person. Matt regrets giving people a text box instead of a drop-down menu.
Do people have a pet hamster? Only 2% do (4 out of 206).
Bec is relieved that people like the podcast and bants, and aren't just there for Matt. People seem to like both Matt's detail and Bec's annoyance at too much detail. The most common request: More than once a month!
Producer John Harvey joins the podcast to give Bec and Matt a bunch of problems. Bec and Matt have at most two minutes to solve the problem, after which Jon Harvey will stop them.
Jon can be followed on Twitter at @jondharvey or @countbinface. Yes, Jon Harvey is Count Binface (once Lord Buckethead).
What exactly defines the difference between a biscuit and a cookie?
Bec says they're the same thing, just a language difference between the states and Australia. Matt notes they might be different in savouriness. Both argue, wasting precious time. John Harvey asks whether the cookie monster would eat a digestive biscuit, Matt suspects yes.
A ding from Jon Harvey
The "fact" that 63 Earths can fit inside Uranus doesn't make clear whether this is a simple volume comparison or whether it's considering sphere packing. Can you shed any light?
Matt previously looked into this, and the answer is: 63 without sphere packing, only 46 with sphere packing. The fact ignores sphere packing. Bec keeps giggling the whole way through.
A "ding" from Jon Harvey
I've never found a four leaf clover. Can you tell me why it is so and how to tip things in my favour?
Bec calls Luke unlucky. Matt points out that the causal direction should be the other way around: Clovers should make you lucky. Matt also recommends searching near Chernobyl.
A "ding" from Jon Harvey
Is the show title "A (Problem)(Problem)" or "(A Problem)(A Problem)"?
"Correct, the title is a problem." - Bec
Matt is fascinated by how people read mathematical equations. He argues that a Mathematician would say "a problem, all squared" for the second case. He parses the title as "A (Problem)(Problem)".
A "(ding)(ding)" from Jon Harvey
If you had a donut shaped planet, I assume that if you went to the center hole, you would experience gravity pulling you to the planet. So, what would happen if you went to the center of the Earth? More gravity being pulled to the surface, or no gravity?
If you were in the middle of a toroidal planet or the Earth, gravity would cancel out. If you're anywhere inside a hollow sphere, no matter where inside the shell you are, everything still cancels out perfectly.
"Well, cause gravity definitely works with my hole." — Bec
A "ding" from Jon Harvey
Bec repeats that if there any undinged problems, you should let them know via one of their social media channels.
From Bec's wide range of puns, Matt settled on the Yule Log Spiral. He shows Bec his final design of a Yule Log with a log spiral on the inside. Bec approves.
Bec has sent Matt a package which he opens live on the podcast: It's the original Yule Log Spiral artwork, the frame of which has been gilded with Ferrero Rocher wrappers from 011-2.
A "That is definitely a problem squared" by Matt
Bec is working on flipcharts for Makeaway Takeaway again. She also got clothes with geometric shapes and dinosaurs as Christmas gifts.
Matt's 40th birthday was right after they stopped recording the last episode. He's difficult to buy gifts for because he just buys the stuff he's interested in, so he just got a lot of unusual coffees and beers.
They also drank a bottle of port Matt got on his 30th birthday, and Lucie has gotten him new bottles for his 50th, 60th and so on. Bec mentions the phrase "Is there any red port left?": Port is the left side of a ship, and airplanes [Editor's note: and ships] have red lights on their left side.
Catherine wants to know if it's possible to cast shadow puppets on the Moon via their house.
Question 1: If it is possible, how big would their hands and torch have to be to cast shadows?
Question 2: Is there a certain place on the earth that works best? Catherine lives in Cheltenham (UK) and wants to know if she should consider moving.
Question 3: If she is standing on Earth with the right equipment, is the distance too great to cast accurate shapes? Would the shadow puppet just become fuzzy beyond recognition?
Question 4: What's the best time of the month or year to do it?
The Moon is a long way away. Bec theorizes that people judge the Moon's size like they judge Bec's height: Always a little too small (which she previously complained about in problem 008-1).
Answer 1: Since the moon is about 100 times as far away as it is large, puppets would also need to be 100 times as far from the torch as they are large. The torch does not need to be massive. Bec realizes that a solar eclipse is just the Moon playing shadow puppets on the Earth.
Answer 2: Stars twinkle because the atmosphere is like a giant instagram filter. Astronomers choose locations that have the fewest cloudy days per year. Curiously, those conditions also make for great holiday destinations... The less atmosphere the better; ideally Catherine could move above the atmosphere.
Answer 3: Even without the atmosphere, you won't get a sharp image/shadow because light is not just particles. Instead, light is slightly bent around edges. "This is a problem that my wife does have on her spacecraft." — Matt.
Answer 4: Bec theorizes the optimal time is the empty (i.e. new) Moon, Matt confirms. But the Moon is a bad screen because it's not very reflective: The Earth reflects about 31% of the light hitting it, the Moon only reflects 12%. Matt didn't work out how much brightness you would need, because it's just not possible.
In short: The solution is "no".
A "ding" by Bec
In the past several years, I've taken to running road races. From observation and participating in many races, I've noticed that the winners always wear the shortest shorts, think 5 cm inseam. The people who come last tend to wear shorts that are 30 cm or longer. Is there any possible correlation between running speed and short lengths?
Bec suspects longer shorts get in the way a bit more. She also suspects that full-time runners will invest in shorts for running whereas the people at the end of a marathon just use their multi-purpose shorts, which Matt confirms from personal experience. If wearing shorter shorts made you faster, Usain Bold would run naked.
Matt brings up a similar phenomenon from cycling: People who cycle a lot tend to shave their legs. There doesn't seem to be a practical reason, except to show your dedication to cycling. Bec mentions a barista's top knot as another example. Bec goes on a looong leg hair tangent.
A "ding" from Matt
In problem 014-3, the question came up whether lucky people exist.
Bec asked on Twitter whether listeners think that lucky people exist. The split was roughly 50%/50%. The luckiest person Bec knows, comedian Sarah Bennetto, explains her own luck: She's been entering competitions and won loads of different types of stuff, including a car on a game show. She also mentions a book that talks about the statistics of winning cars.
Matt believes there's no such thing as luck, but there are lucky people. Random processes don't consistently turn out better than expected, but some people make more opportunities or are good at capitalizing on them. Notably, this doesn't mean that past success will lead to more success in the future. For example, Matt suspects Bennetto enters a lot of competitions. He also mentions the Dream Minecraft speedrunning drama.
Matt looked for the book, but couldn't find it and is now asking listeners for help. Bec is prepared to ding the problem when the book is found.
People on social media have brought to Bec's attention that they are not the same. Some biscuit companies will also call some crackers biscuits. You wouldn't put cheese on a cookie. Bec has reassessed the problem and has come to the conclusion that there is a spectrum of baked goods and that we should respect the product's label.
According to a tweet, there's a similar naming problem in Brazilian social media.
The website now sends you to a page where you can submit a problem. This doesn't mean that other channels will be ignored, but the form is the preferred solution. Even if you post it somewhere else, you can put the link to the post in the form. The podcast also has a brand new problem curator: Steph Keegan.
Matt has been making a video on Dream's luck, which he mentioned last episode in problem 015-3. In this video, a running gag is there are a few shots where he's unnaturally lucky, which took a long time to film. The video performed quite well after the Minecraft community got a hold of it. He also mentions that his high-effort Christmas tree video from episode 014 (news) did not perform as well as he'd hoped while his low-effort "running guest code" video performed surprisingly better.
After her appearance on 8 Out of 10 Cats does Comedy Countdown, people started following her and saying lovely things. Bec finds it nice to see that TV still works.
Both of my parents are teachers, and they're teaching from home via Zoom in the current lockdown. One of them has asked every member of the class to bake some biscuits for their maths lesson — measuring, units, etc. My question is: What's the best way for them to share the biscuits with one another?
Originally, this problem was planned for 015, but it had to be pushed back because Matt was too deep in the maths. [Editor's note: biscuits and cookies were previously mentioned in 014-1]
A first approach: Everyone gives them to Bec, and assuming Bec doesn't eat them all, she distributes them to everyone again. For n people, this takes 2n - 3 journeys. After some diversions on cookie parties, Matt has found out that this is not the optimal solution. With the help of some shitty Python code and the Online Encyclopedia of Integer Sequences (OEIS), Matt has found someone else's solution for exactly this problem from 1972, though back then it was called the telephone problem.
Bec recommends a solution where cookies are passed in a big circle, which is apparently the second best solution and takes the same number of journeys as Matt's initial solution. With a bit of extra faff, you can get rid of exactly one more journey, which is the theoretical maximum.
Bec dinged it, Matt will pass on the ding to Raphi, who can then pass it on to their parents.
Tim wants to be efficient with their annual leave and wants to make the most of the time they have off. "Can you please help suggest some interesting ways to elongate the days I have off work in 2021?" They're happy for creative solutions. They were originally thinking of taking the day off when the clocks go back to get a 25 hour day, but that's always on the weekend.
Matt talks about an experiment where people falling were experiencing time differently due to panic. He suggests spending your holiday perpetually falling. Bec suggests skydiving over the international date line. Matt suggests hiring someone to scare Tim occasionally during his holiday. Bec suggests taking her along. Matt shares anecdotes from travelling with Bec, including one about breaking a phone. Bec suggests Tim comes with them to the Edinburgh Fringe and do all their driving and props.
Bec doesn't think she deserves a ding. Awaiting feedback from Tim. Matt will add a dropdown to the Problem Posing Page from episode 015 (news) where you can select "solution".
A different mathematician, Kit Yates, has calculated the coronavirus volume again, and it's being picked up by newspapers again. They've got a much larger value of 160 ml, about half a soda can. Matt was invited to the same BBC episode that Kit was also on, and they both talked about their calculations. Matt explains the differences between their approaches.
Since a virus is effectively just data, Matt wanted to know how much data the can would contain. A single virus RNA contains roughly 7.5 kB of data. The half soda can of virus is equivalent to roughly 600 million 1 TB hard drives. Given that only roughly 2% of the virus RNA is actively used, it would only make for 12.5 million 1 TB hard drives.
Bec notes that a small bottle of Corona beer is 210 ml. You could have an actual bottle of corona(virus).
Dom, on Instagram, sent a message mentioning Courtney Dauwalter, known for her knee-length shorts, and Sabrina Verjee, who also wore knee-length running tights. Once you go over 100 km and off-road, the length also seems to increase with distance.
Matt asked a friend Kenny [Editor's note: Spelling likely incorrect], who used to run ultramarathons. He liked to use longer shorts to avoid sun burns, but guessed that shorter shorts might help with sweating and cooling, though he has not noticed a difference.
Bec contacted her sister-in-law, who has won Paralympics medals for sprinting. She said she never thought about it in terms of length, but she liked wearing the little shorts and top because she looks great in them. It's a psychological factor where you want other people to see how good you are, which also might give you an edge.
Bec is very tired because she's filming Makeaway Takeaway. Matt knows she's been busy because he's no longer getting text messages and phone calls. She's rediscovered a playlist she originally put together for Matt.
Since the last recording, she's gotten news that the first three books of a series she's writing, Horror Heights, will be coming out.
While Bec has been busy, Matt has discovered a hole in his house. While he has temporarily shoved some paper towels in the hole, he has a better plan. During winter, you live in a warm box in a cold environment that takes energy to maintain. Your fridge is a cold box inside that warm box that takes even more energy to maintain. Instead, Matt intends to somehow connect the fridge to the cold outside through the hole. He's ordered some insulated conduit already, but has yet to obtain an old fridge to cut a hole in. Bec notes that this is a better use for an old fridge than keeping it running, following advice from problem 001-3.
How many Bec Hills could fit in Bexhill? [Editor's note: Bexhill is a town, and not in fact a hill.]
Bec has never been to Bexhill. Matt frequents Matthew Parker Street, and has even been to Bexhill, just after they broke the world record for number of mermaids in a single area. In 2012, Bexhill was found to have the highest amount of centenarians in the UK. In October 2021, the East Sussex Astronomical Society will be hosting Lucie Green (Matt's wife) as their speaker.
Bec has scrawled all her calculations on her hand, which are slightly smudged. Bexhill is 32.31 km². Instead of measuring her own diameter (see problem 011-2), she measured her rectangular dimensions, which are 29 cm by 45 cm. The answer: 247'586'206 Bec Hills fit in Bexhill.
But how many actual people called Bec Hill can fit in Bexhill? With the help of some websites, she estimated that there are 81 Bec Hills in the world. However, that's only those born as "Bec", not "Rebecca". Including Rebeccas, there should be 23'757 Bec Hills in the world. Bexhill currently has about twice as many residents, so the answer is: Every Bec Hill could live in Bexhill.
A "That's 100% a ding, well done" from Matt
If you got every animal, which species would form the longest queue when all individuals of that species would be queuing up.
Matt asks Bec for her intuition. She suggests rats or cockroaches. Producer Jon guesses cows, which are big and there are a lot. There's a also lots of chickens. Lucie guessed worms.
Matt could not find a good database for animal species population sizes nor animal sizes, so he had to do the calculations by hand. Humans in a queue lying down would be 13 million km long, but standing up it would only be 2.2 million km long. If humans can't lie down, cows are about 3.6 million km long, and chickens are about 11.6 million km long. Ants across species would be 54.7 billion km long, which makes about 4 million km if you assume they're distributed into species randomly. There is no clear answer. Biology is a mess.
Excluding bacteria and worms, the answer is humans (if we're allowed to lie down), otherwise chickens.
A "I think that is worthy of a ding" by Bec
Bec was contacted by a company called HigherDOSE, who sell sauna blankets, a kind of very hot electric sleeping bag. They sent one out, and Bec filmed herself in it and put it on YouTube (the video has graphs). With the jacket on, her body temperature was significantly lower at the end of the experiment. Matt suspects that the jacket only buys you time, but at the end the jacket will catch up. With the jacket on, it might even get worse.
An "absolute ding" by Matt, and a "ding" by Bec
Matt has now located and purchased a fridge for his house hole project. It is currently standing in the hallway [Editor's note: see 011-3].
Oh, and he also has a dog now: Skylab the labrador. Matt has created a dog vlog YouTube channel for her, and he also has a spreadsheet of everything she has cost him.
Studio filming for Makeaway Takeaway is done, only location filming is left. Some anecdotes ensue, including one where Bec falls backwards out of shot.
In an upcoming election, I want to vote for a novelty candidate, not just because I think it would be funny, but also because I think they would be good if they won. But I'm also aware that novelty candidates rarely ever win, and I'm worried that voting for them could be an irresponsible use of my vote. What should I do?
Matt is an amateur voting system nerd. The system used in the UK is first-past-the post, where the candidate with the most votes wins. Australia has (compulsory, with democracy sausages) ranked-choice voting, where you rank candidates instead of voting for a single candidate. As candidates drop out, your vote rolls down your list to the next candidate. For completeness, there is also is approval voting, where you mark all candidates that you would approve of winning, and the candidate with the most approvals wins. Matt mentions Arrow's impossibility theorem, which states that no voting system can be perfect. Nonetheless, some voting systems are better in practice.
In conclusion, first-past-the-post (and approval voting) encourage strategic voting. If it's going to be close, maybe don't vote instead of the novelty candidate. Bec reveals she was the novelty candidate once. She also mentions Antanas Mockus, who was a mayor in Columbia with over-the-top but working initiatives.
Finally, the big reveal: Bec was considering voting for Count Binface, who appears live on the podcast. He notes the London mayor election does not use a first-past-the-post system. Because many seats in the UK's system are safe, novelty candidates like Boris Johnson and Donald Trump do arise from time to time.
How do I explain Eurovision to Americans?
It's X-Factor, but where the contestants are countries, and crossed with a circus.
A "ding, that works" by Matt
What's something I can say or do to make a good impression when meeting people for the first time?
Bec briefly did door-to-door sales. One of her co-workers, now-comedian Chris Knight, would have a pack of cards. As people opened their door, he'd hold up a card and ask "Is this your card?". Matt holds up a card and asks Bec the same question, though sadly it was not Bec's card.
Bec also suggests to use people's names more often, both to remember it better and because people like hearing their own name. Matt suggests asking people about themselves. Bec suggests body language mirroring, or matching the energy. She also suggests showing up on time. Though if you're in a position of power, be very slightly late.
If the location name "Wyoming" was a name (i.e. running, parachuting, kerploding), what would it mean?
It's the verb of wyome. Matt thought it was to question why you're meditating (why omm?). Bec suggests it's being unsure when asking questions (why — umm...). Urban dictionary suggests "wondering" or "wandering", or "to flap about like a worm". Matt googles that it comes from a word meaning "at the big river flat", so "wyoming" means arriving at such a river flat.
A "ding" by Bec
How many podcasts should I subscribe to?
There's no "too many", subscribe to as many as you want to listen to. Bec listens to lots of podcasts. She suggests "Office Ladies", "Swindled".
A "ding" by Matt
How many people have successfully faked their own death?
Bec doesn't know the answer, but she recommends the true crime podcast "Casefile", who are releasing a new series "Pseudocide" about people who fake their own deaths. Matt reckons you might be able to estimate it if you have different methods for measuring population size, e.g. sewage. Bec notes that if somebody is claiming to be dead, they're lying. But after a certain amount of time, any fake death becomes a real death.
An "I think your advice to go listen to a podcast about it is the best ding we're going to give it" by Matt.
Scott submitted a solution to the Problem Posing page: Antarctic krill. There are a lot of them (approx. 500 million tons, according to one study), and they're bigger than you would expect (6 cm). He estimates that the length is 15 billion km, which is a bit longer than humanity's 13 million km.
A very special, limited edition ding.
Matt shows Bec another card (like in 018-3) and asks "Is this your card?" Bec says no.
Bec is still very busy with Makeaway Takeaway, and she'll continue to be busy for about a month. She handled some surprisingly heavy horse manure, and will go to a skate park soon.
"I'm kick flipping in the cupboard right as I talk." — Bec
Matt's been busy with videos that become more and more elaborate and time consuming. Matt rambles a bit about the fourth dimension and physicists.
Six months ago, I found a hamster in my apartment. None of the neighbours claimed him [though the problem poser does not know if it's really a him]. I don't know if it's really a hamster or a mouse with its tail cut off, I don't know how old he is, but most importantly, I still have no idea where he came from. I live in Pakistan, we don't have hamsters. WHERE DID HE COME FROM??
Bec got a photo and video of Hammie and she can confirm that it is indeed a (short haired Syrian) hamster. She has experience with hamsters, in particular a Russian dwarf hamster called Pudding first mentioned in episode 012 (news). It seems he may have testicles. While you can cut a hamster in half and count the rings, it will probably not help determine its age. Hamsters tend to live two years, so Hammie is probably not older than that.
Hamsters are not illegal in Pakistan (unlike Australia) and there are hamster breeders in the problem poser's town, so it's likely someone's pet. Hammie didn't seem to be in best shape, so it may have been a neighbour getting rid of their pet. On the other hand, hamsters can run up to 9 km a night, as mentioned in 012 (news), so maybe Hammie came from a neighbourhood a few km away. Hamsters are also very good climbers and used to tight spaces, which explains how Hammie made their way into the apartment.
If you find a hamster, you should know this: Hamsters need a lot of space (because they like to run), and ideally not something tall made of bars (else they might slip and break their back). A big multipurpose plastic box (with holes and mesh for ventilation) or an IKEA Detolf display cabinet laid on its side make for good cages.
"There's some good hamster porn." — Bec
A full ding by the problem poser
Pudding's cage is 36 in by 17 in (91.44 cm by 43.18 cm). Hamster's should have a minimum of 6 in (15.24 cm) of bedding so that they can burrow. One bag of bedding is 49.2 l, which equals 3000 in³. The question is: How many bags of bedding, or what proportion of a bag, is needed to provide Pudding with 6 in deep of bedding?
If humans were able to grow trunks and leaves to use photosynthesis to harness energy from the sun, how big would our human leafy crown have to be to sustain our daily energy expenditure?
Matt needs about 2'500 kcal per day, which is 10'460'000 J per day, or roughly 121 W. Plants have a worse efficiency than solar panels and produce around 8.1 W per m³. This means Matt would need around 15 m² of leaves; roughly a square twice as big as his height. If you exert yourself carrying around a big trunk, you might easily need twice as much energy. Bec notes that this is why trees don't walk around. Matt notes the similarity to the rocket equation.
A "ding" by Bec
Professor Andrea Sella at the UCL, who is a professor of inorganic chemistry, recorded an answer. According to chemists, plastic is dry (hydrophobic, water forms beads) while ceramic is wet (hydrophilic, water spreads out). Matt and Bec take photos of angles of droplets on various materials. When you open your dishwasher, the water on the ceramics is spread out thinly and evaporates quickly, while the beads on the plastic evaporate more slowly.
An "A ding to Bec" by Matt
It is not Bec's card.
This WA Day (Western Australia Day), Matt was the Distant Relative™ via facetime. His family was trying to burn out a tree stump in the back yard, for the 10th time.
During lunch, a production assistant brought ice cream cones to the "beach" and was attacked by seagulls, who stole both cones.
I'm wondering whether the planet is warming because of the increased relative proportion of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, or the absolute amount. If it's the proportion, then could we alleviate the problem (theoretically at least) by putting loads more nitrogen and oxygen into the atmosphere?
We usually talk about it in ppm (parts per million), which is relative. Matt compares CO₂ to the bouncer of a club who lets high-frequency radiation through but not low-frequency radiation. The same amount of bouncers in a hallway that's twice as long are still as likely to catch you as before. However, the Earth is a sphere, so diluting would actually have a slightly positive effect. This apparently corresponds to a club where the bouncers stop you from leaving because you're too sober.
While it may technically work, you'd need about 85 times the atmosphere to reduce the greenhouse effect to pre-industrial levels. This would increase the atmospheric pressure by 85 times, while the human record (some deep sea diver) is around 75 times. If we manage to live like this, global warming is solved!
Bec is not giving it a ding until they hear back from any deep sea divers.
Andrew thought of this because in episode 018 (news), Bec mentioned she likes falling over like a plank. Andrew however has a medical condition which causes them to pass out randomly and unexpectedly. This goes along with a condition that means they dislocate their joints when doing this rather than breaking them. How would you reduce injury and/or make it the most funny? Since life is limited, less pain and more laughing is always good.
Bec is not giving pain relief or medical advice. She mentions Rowan Atkinson's "Funny Business", which Matt has also seen. Matt warns that standup comedians talking about comedy is a very dry subject.
Context: Something serious can be made funny if you know the consequences are not serious. Bec proposes Andrew should either only frequent soft places (bouncy castles, trampolines, pillow factories), or Andrew could wear something soft and protective.
Incongruenty: Pattern breaking, related to the rule of three. Anything can be funny if it appears somewhere unexpected (horse in an office), looks unexpected (the horse is tiny), or behaves unexpected (the horse is answering the phone). Andrew passing out unexpectedly is already funny by that measure.
Superiority/ranking: Andrew should look like they have a lot of money or power, i.e. should dress like the Monopoly man.
Public shaming: Something happening to you is funnier if you look like you deserve it (e.g. running over an ice lake). Andrew should be a jerk all the time, steal candy, down low too slow, ...
Relief: Building up tension and then releasing it, usually in verbal comedy and story telling. This would require timing on Andrew's part, which is not applicable.
Psychological distance: If you're distant (e.g. they're on TV, you don't like them), you might find it funnier.
Matt also suggests a T-Shirt with "It's okay, I thought it was funny as well" on the back. Bec warns of an "explosion at a clown factory", where too much funny factors make something unfunny.
Bec's conclusion: Andrew needs to become a sports mascot. It's padded and cartoony. Sports games have a lot of tension, relieved by mascots. They also are priviledged, getting to interact with the players. You're physically distant and thus psychologically distant. This is both career and life advice.
Matt tells an anecdote where he wore a galah mascot costume and ran into windows. He entered the video into Australia's Funniest Home Videos and got 500 bucks for it. Bec hopes Matt or a listener will find the footage.
Awaiting ding from Andrew.
@christhechemist wanted to know if Matt factored in the energy required for maintaining the leaves. Matt confirmed that he did.
Dexter (now aged 8 113/365) did a Dexter again and got to the same result as Bec, which is 1.224 bags. He also sent a drawing of the cage, which includes Pudding.
People are still sending in species suggestions, including the Pelegibacter ubique, a type of SAR11 bacteria. All SAR11 bacteria would form a line 10 times the width of the Milky Way galaxy, but include lots of species again. Matt is not convinced, and accepts the arctic krill as the final answer. No further solutions are accepted.
At the time of recording, the podcast has hit 200 Patreon supporters. Sophie is officially the 200th supporter. The podcast is on track for the current goal of pi hundred supporters in the second year, mentioned in problem 012-5.
A new survey is running to help with a problem for one of the next episodes. Matt wants to know what people call the substance they put on their skin when they go out into the sun.
Bec and Matt thank and welcome their new producer, Lauren Armstrong-Carter.
It is not Bec's card.
Filming has concluded, editing is next. The last big thing filmed involved a neighbourhood, after which cute little kids went around and took tea and coffee orders. Bec had a lovely time.
Matt came off his bicycle at considerable speed, but he's faring well. He tells some more biking and accident anecdotes, including doing maths in the emergency room to pass the time.
He had to buy a new helmet because the old one was involved in the accident. Now he doesn't know what to do with it. Listeners are encouraged to send in ideas for what to do with it.
On his way up the stairs, he slipped because he wasn't supposed to move his injured knee, breaking a toe on his other foot.
"Dogs famously lick things that heal." — Matt
Have you ever felt like your dings were missing something? What's the closest that the human vocal apparatus can get to mimicking the "ding" of an actual bell?
Bec starts by explaining the basics of sound, frequency, volume, partials, and harmonics/inharmonics with the analogy of throwing differently sized balls from a roof. She demonstrates overtones by singing, after which she plays a clip by singer Anna-Maria Hefele for comparison.
Bec brings on Beardyman (Jay Foreman's brother), who explains the difference between the human vocal tract and a ringing metal object. Some resonances will be canceling each other out and some reinforcing each other, as previously described in 005-1. Beardyman also explains the basics of attack, sustain, and release. He then creates a bell-like noise from his voice with the help of a frequency shifter. Apparently, the lyrebird is also capable of introducing inharmonics because it kind of has two throats.
The human voice might be able to mimic a bell if you find a way to produce inharmonics and have a quick attack and long release. If any listener is capable of this, they should get in contact.
"Inharmonics is just harmonics you don't like." — Matt
A Beardyman ding
Now that the weather is getting better, I need to use sunscreen, otherwise I get burnt. But I don't want to use too much sunscreen, otherwise I don't get a tan at all and am therefore more susceptible to sunburn. How do I optimize my usage of sunscreen?
To an Australian, a healthy tan is like a relaxing concussion. You get burnt by UV rays from the sun, which are the high-frequency parts of the spectrum. The warmth you feel is the low-frequency, infrared range. The most dangerous radiation, UV-C, is blocked by the ozone layer. UV-B is only partially stopped, and sunscreens mostly block this part. The bulk of UV radiation is UV-A, which is not as dangerous but still not perfect.
There is a technical difference between a sunblock and a sunscreen: A sunblock deflects the radiation, while a sunscreen absorbs the radiation (and breaks down in the process, which is why you have to reapply it). The factor is which fraction of light is let through: Factor 30 means ¹/₃₀ of the light makes it through. Factors are determined by intentionally sunburning a poor volunteer.
The results from the survey are in. Matt wanted to see if countries name their sun protection positive or negative depending on the sun severity. Australia and the USA are pretty sun-negative, while the UK is a bit more sun-positive. There's not a big correlation with age.
Having a tan is somewhere in the region of SPF 2 to 4. Putting on less sunscreen because you have a tan is a dangerous game to play. No UV exposure is safe exposure. Always put on your sunscreen.
A "ding" by Bec and a Beardyman ding
Andrew has sent a tweet saying that with their dislike of sport, their life is now wearing a michelin man suit while dressed in full ceremonial lord mayor's outfit while kicking puppies in a bouncy castle.
A "DING" by Andrew
Neil, a scuba diver instructor, responds with some scuba facts. Saturation divers don't sound squeaky because of the helium, but because the speed of sound is higher in the denser air. They also suffer from bone necrosis, which is something to watch out for in the high pressure utopia.
"You can't solve climate change by diluting the atmosphere, if you wanna keep your bones." — Matt
A "full ding" by Bec and a Beardyman ding
It is not Bec's card.
Two people have been sending Matt new maths things. He has received a new dodecahedron and a 4030 digit digitally delicate prime number.
Makeaway Takeaway starts on CITV on 17:30 on 2021-09-06.
For a hen do, Bec went to an old nuclear bunker. Matt would've been in his element. There was a cool old computer with an unknown language. Bec got safely inebriated. Matt would be up for an on-location recording session.
How to avoid burning out with writing and ways to keep it fun and interesting
Bec and Matt talk about the books they're writing. When Bec was writing episodes for children's shows, they were so short she didn't get bored. Writing a rough first draft is quick, but honing it takes a long time. Don't worry about making it perfect on the first go, that's just wasted energy. You have to be okay with making a bad thing, but you do get to fix it later.
Sometimes Bec wears differently-colored 3D glasses. Sometimes she switches up the font, e.g. Comic Sans (all of Matt's books have been written in Verdana). Bec has bought an E-Ink tablet and a clacky bluetooth keyboard to kind of emulate a type writer, which makes writing more fun. Matt has some fidget toys nearby and he likes throwing things in the air and leaning very far back in the chair.
Don't write for more than three or four hours at a time, otherwise you'll not be very productive. Matt recommends to stop writing when you're excited, and to write down a few ideas. This way, you'll have a good starting point the next day. Matt uses post-it notes on his wall to structure his books.
Awaiting ding from James.
It's easy to look at a star that's light years away, but I was wondering where on Earth you can look the furthest away at something that is also on Earth. As in: What's the longest line between two points on Earth that doesn't go through the Earth, and where are those two points?
Matt first wanted to know what's the furthest thing away that you can see with your bare eyes: It's the Andromeda galaxy. From time to time, supernovae further away are also visible. Bec wants to coin the term "blip" for a supernova you can see with the naked eye.
The taller you are, the further away the horizon is. Matt recounts a related Lucie anecdote. Matt has a spreadsheet to calculate personal horizons. If you built a tower up the the line where space starts, you could see just over 2000 km in every direction. From the tallest existing building, the Burj Khalifa, you could see 103 km, and there is a direct line of sight to the top of the tallest building in Abu Dhabi. Bec asks about two mountains; Matt is open for suggestions.
Waiting for a reply from Lois.
When eating cereal, what is the milk? Sauce, broth, jus, or something else?
Bec did some research: It's milk! It's not broth, jus, gravy, soup, or stock, because those all involve boiling the ingredients to get the flavour out of them. A sauce is made out of a variety of ingredients, which milk is not. It's a bit like cold-brew tea where you eat the tea, or like custard. If you added some stuff to the milk before pouring it, it could be a sauce.
A simultaneous Bec "ding" and Beardyman ding
Matt was just going to throw the helmet out. The most popular suggestion was a hanging basket. John suggested returning it to the manufacturer with a description of what happened. You will help provide real-world data and you might even get a discount on your replacement helmet. Matt liked this suggestion and will send his helmet back.
Bec has forgotten what her card was.
This episode is being recorded in person. The last previous in-person episode was 002. Listeners are encouraged to tweet "cupboard" or "nupboard", depending on whether they like or dislike this change.
The first episode of Makeaway Takeaway has finally aired. If you like Bec's adult/standup stuff, you will also like her kid's stuff. Matt likes it.
Bec has also started the Anime to Z podcast.
Security at the Shard took Matt's prospector because they said it could be used as a weapon. They also confiscated Hannah Fry's inclinometer. Similar to 022-2, they wanted to measure how far they could see, and then use that to derive the radius of the earth.
Matt once had to get his Rubik's Cube put through an X-Ray machine because he was doing maths sessions in a jail.
"My plumb is just dangling." — Matt
Bec and Matt ask people to promote the podcast and donate to the Patreon, if possible. Don't leave Matt dangering.
If you rolled up graphene into a roll the size of a toilet paper roll, how long would it be?
Graphene is a one atom thick material that's very strong for its mass. According to a paper, an accurate thickness measurement is difficult because measuring it squashes it, but it's rougly 0.5 nm high. Approximating the Achimedean spiral using concentric circles, Matt arrives at a length of 20'000 km, which is halfway around the Earth.
"Give me two rolls of graphene toilet paper and a place to stand, and I will TP the world." — Matt, paraphrasing Achimedes
A tentative "ding" from Bec
My brother told me that every time he reads a paper book, he wonders how much the book would weigh without any ink. If you had a totally useless representation of a book, how many pages could you save by just printing the ink without any gaps?
Bec's Horror Heights book is being released on the date of this episode, 2021-09-30, and she got a tour of the factory. She nerds out about the printing process. Bec asked Beth and Ollie from Clays Printing (who printed her book), who estimated 11.2 g per book. Each book is 157.3g, which makes 146.1g per inkless book. The ink is about 7.12% of the mass.
Matt wrote a bit of Python code to count pixels of ink in Bec's book. After some fun stats, he reveals you'd only need 24.22 pages full of ink to equal the 176 actual pages. Matt uses this opportunity to talk about the difference between the mean and median.
A "solid ding, margin to margin" from Bec and Matt
People were upset at Matt for not including mountains and sent in lots of suggestions. The highest peak in Tenerife to the highest peak in Gran Canaria are over 100 km apart. From Pico Cristóbal Colón to the ocean (if possible) would be 270 km. From a peak in Arizona to Humphrey's Peak would be 187 km. From Mauna Kea in Hawaii you might get 128 km. From Aconcagua to the ocean would be 298 km. However, these are all just theories.
The world record for the longest photograph from Spain to France is 443 km. This takes into account refraction through the air. Bec criticises that, had Matt googled the answer, he'd found out about this answer straight away.
A solid ding from Bec, which turns out to be a Beardyman ding
A bunch of listeners have responded on Twitter with their own writing tips. Matt likes the vibrating pen idea.
PositronicGirl responded that Bec's solution was adequate.
A Beardyman ding as a meta-ding
Bec has chosen a new card, which she will message producer Lauren.
Matt went to Leeds because friend Seb Lee-Delisle had a laser installation there. Leeds train station recently opened their platform 0, so Matt had to visit that as well.
Bec had a book launch of her first Horror Heights book. Many play things were present, but Matt did not attend. However, Matt has a list of geometrically interesting children's playgrounds.
What is the largest single hole relative to the size of the pumpkin one can carve out of a pumpkin without the pumpkin collapsing? How should one cut said hole?
You can cut a hole in the pumpkin that is bigger than the pumpkin, which does not involve deforming the pumpkin. This is related to the Prince Rupert's cube, where you cut a hole through a cube that you can fit the cube through. Matt verified this fact in a practical experiment with two same-sized pumpkins, one of which he cut a hole into. The other pumpkin then fits through the hole. He used the smallest pointiest knife, and he never cut towards himself because it would slip very easily.
Bec decides to wait for a ding from Eric, even though she personaly considers the problem dinged. Bec wonders at which point it ceases to be a hole in a pumpkin, like the point where a bowl turns into a plate.
How do I stop the ghosts in my place from rattling all the doors during the night when I'm trying to sleep and I have to get up at 4am for the early shift at work? I've pleaded with them, had a stern talking to them, but they won't listen.
Bec suggests the ghosts might not be the problem, and instead Greg should fix the rattling doors. She quizzes Matt on the names of door parts, then explains them in detail.
One of the common causes for door rattling is that the strike plate is too big, which causes the latch to move around and rattle. You can also use weather stripping on the door jamb, which not only stops rattling but also minimizes sound leakage. You could wedge the door, or use plastic strip courtains instead of doors.
A door fun fact from Bec: January is named after Janus, who is the god of doors.
In case the ghosts are the problem and not the doors, Bec looked up what to do about noisy flat mates. Don't confront them directly but talk calmly. Be ready to accept compromises. Maybe escalate along official channels if this didn't help. To get rid of the ghosts, try burning sage (to a CD-ROM, ghosts hate pirates). Sound reiki might also work, both for spiritual people and for geology nerds.
"Finding common ground: Rocks" — Matt
The people have spoken. In a Twitter poll, 539 people have voted, and 59% (319 people) wanted Bec to go back in the cupboard. Bec suspects that some voters were not listeners. Incidentally, this episode was recorded with Bec in the cupboard again. Matt suggests another poll that asks whether people took the previous poll seriously.
After last episode's Patreon ad brought in more Patreon supporters, Matt has developed a spreadsheet that randomly selects three patrons for Bec and Matt to thank at the end of each episode. They go on to thank the first batch.
Bec went to an opera with the famous drinking song. Everything was great, except the story.
Matt and Lucie (his wife, who is a solar physicist) are going to see a solar eclipse. To see it, you have to be on a ship close to the Antarctic. It's a rare eclipse that goes the wrong way (East to West) because you're on the other side of the pole and thus East and West are flipped. The ship have a science lab, which Matt is excited about. He's not allowed to catch an Antarctic krill from episode 018 (update), but they might wash up dead on the coast of Antarctica.
Matt requests ideas from listeners for what problems to solve while he's in the Antarctic circle. Matt mentions a few plans he has, but hopes for good suggestions. He'll be on the ship when this episode releases, so he can't take anything special with him.
If everyone in the world gave me one in their local currency, how much money would I have in Euros?
Some countries accept multiple currencies, in which case Matt is using the most local currency with an ISO abbreviation. He then wrote some code to google the exchange rates. The worst case is Indonesia, which is the 4th most populated country with one of the worst value-per-unit rates. The best exchange rates are Kuwait, Bahrain, Oman.
The overall result is 1'229'461'715 €. The average person would give you 0.158 €.
A "ding" and a "ka-ching" from Bec
Building on 017-1: How many Beck's fit in Bec Hill (both by consumption and theoretical total volume)?
By consumption: Bec and Matt drank as many Beck's as they could and recorded the process. Some of the beers they drank were non-alcoholic ones. Bec complains that Matt was a terrible control. Once you use the bathroom, the experiment stops. In the end, both drank 6 bottles, which comprises a third of what they bought.
By volume: Bec has looked at X-Rays, but the max amount of bottles were one. She also asked two sword swallowers, Snookie Mono and Snake Fervor, about this. Both said "don't swallow bottles, you will die". Conclusion: Don't insert any bottles in any way, it's not safe. She also reached out to two doctors, Adam Kay and Doctor Xand, who said that skin is very stretchy and suggested surgically implanting the bottles.
To measure her volume, Bec had a bath at Matt's house. Matt then calculated the volume of the displaced water, which was 56.5l. In beer, that's the content of 205.5 bottles.
Eric replied: So cool that you answered my hole-in-pumpkin question. My initial thought was as Bec mentioned, as it came to me while carving a pumpkin. However, Matt was right with his answer to the stated question. Of course a pumpkin is not a Jack-o-Lantern.
Matt's companion video had several unimpressed commenters, who said it was obvious because you can move a door through its own frame. He reckons this won't work with anything with a spherical cross section.
Matt's pumpkin hole has been turned into a somewhat pathetic Jack-o-Lantern.
A "full ding from me" from Eric
The current episode is recorded with Bec outside the cupboard in Matt's office. A few people felt bad that they sent Bec back to the cupboard, and replied on Twitter. There was no supermajority vote (⅔), so there will be no big changes as a result of the poll.
After thanking 3 randomly selected patrons, Bec reminds listeners that they have until 2021-12-07 to subscribe if they want this year's christmas card.
It is not Bec's card.
Bec requests a Christmas gift from the listeners: Reviews on iTunes. Apparently, they really help.
The reviews are in, and there are two. Bec and Matt read them aloud.
Matt's trip was successful. Apparently there was a lot of paperwork, and some Covid shenanigans. The solar eclipse was cloudy, but the trip was worth it. 17 ships ended up in the path of the eclipse, only one of which saw the eclipse.
Bec went to her first red carpet event. She didn't have red-carpet-worthy clothing, so she made her own dress with things she had in her flat. It was her first time making clothes. The mathematical name for the shape of her circle skirt is an annulus. She used an old pair of pants as her top.
"I wore an anus." — Bec
How fast could a team of penguins complete a 4x100 relay race? Could they field a competitive (or uncompetitive) olympic team for Antarctica in 2024?
Matt spoke to a penguin expert (a human) on the ship, and he saw a lot of penguins, which he thinks are a stupid animal. On land, penguins are slow because they have no land-based predators. The fastest penguin is the
Gentoo (which Matt hears as "Gen. 2"), which goes 35.4 kmh under water. It would do a 100 m sprint in 10.17 s. Obviously, they would use fish batons. The entire race would take 40.67 s, which is better than the current women's record (on land) but worse than the current men's record (on land). They'd be a lot faster than the human swimming records.
On land, penguins can waddle and slide on their stomachs. Matt took a video of two penguins doing just that, and estimated their speeds. The waddling penguin went 0.7 m/s while the sliding penguin went 1.75 m/s. The waddling race would take 9 minutes 31 seconds, while the sliding race would take 5 minutes 26 seconds.
A simultaneous Bec "ding" and Beardyman ding
How can I fix my sleeping schedule? For the past year or so, it seems to have gotten worse and worse. I am a grad student and I have to work a lot, often into the night. But then I wake up very late in the day. I feel guilty about sleeping and stay up even later the next day, and sleep in even later. It doesn't matter how many alarms I set, I can't seem to wake up at a decent time. I have even tried multiple times to stay up all night, hoping to reset to a normal bedtime the next day, but that does not stick.
PS: As part of this endeavour, I've tried to stop looking at my phone before bed because I always hear that the changing lights stimulate your brain and prevent you from sleeping. No scrolling through social media or watching videos. Your podcast has been something relaxing that I can listen to but not watch while getting ready for bed.
Bec builds an analogy for the circadian rhythm based on a smart home with a control hub in the kitchen. There's multiple circadian rhythms, all connected to each other, and they can be disrupted.
Bec thinks Sleepy should let their body adjust to their current sleep cycle before trying to set a new sleep cycle. It might not be the schedule they want but it would be a schedule. They should then stay in that schedule for a few days. Circadian rhythms don't like hard resets (which is also why you have jet lag). As a rule of thumb, you should calculate one 24h cycle for one hour of time difference.
More tips: As soon as you wake up, get some sun light on you. Bec uses an alarm clock that slowly becomes brighter, which is great. No caffeine within 5 hours of your bedtime. Exercise helps a lot (Bec speaks from experience). Holidays are a good time to start new habits because your body is already in disarray a bit. Sleep in a cool room. Set your alarm earlier by small increments (e.g. 30 minutes).
Finally, there's A people (early birds) and B people (night owls), which is probably based on genetics and not possible to change. Different countries have different sleeping habits. Greece goes to bed the latest. Matt sleeps like a spanish woman.
Awaiting reply from Sleepy.
Fred (and some other listeners) noted that you might not be able to give one of a currency because there's not a coin or bill for it. Matt assumed you could just do a bank transfer.
Anonymous pointed out that it's a common myth that Comic Sans was developed for people with dyslexia. Producer Lauren, who as dyslexia, says dfferent fonts don't help her, but a black background color does.
The annual listener survey has started again. Listeners are encouraged to submit their answers.
It is not Bec's card. But it is Bec's post-it note that she left all around Matt's house.
Three more reviews are in, which Matt and Bec read aloud.
Bec previously had her office in the kitchen. She convinced her husband to merge the lounge and bedroom into a "blounge". The ex-bedroom now houses a walk-in wardrobe and Bec's office. It can also double as a spare room for visitors. Bec has also put her life-like copy of her own head on a shelf in her room. [Editor's note: That's one solution to problem 010-3.]
This episode is being recorded in Matt's office again.
At the time of recording, Matt is 14998 days old. In two days will be his 15000th day-birthday (on a Sunday). In comparison, Bec is 12855 days old.
Matt notes that 2022-02-22 is Two's Day Tuesday, for which he's planning to release a video.
I love the podcast. It has been keeping me sane whilst I've been going through radiotherapy for a brain tumor. I've now finished my therapy and received a mesh mask of my face/head that was needed to hold my head still throughout my radiotherapy sessions. What should I do with the mask? My wife is an artist and I've thought about asking her to paint it like a popular arachnid-based superhero, but I think there could be a more creative answer out there.
Bec, who has a copy of her own head — 027 (news) — notes the difference between a mask and a head. People commonly do cool stuff with their radiotherapy masks.
Bec's ideas: Wastepaper basket, novelty basketball hoop, use it for fencing, pop it into a hot bath and remold it, ice sculpting, make a massive jelly/jello (and serve it in the blounge room), papier-mâché it and make it look like somebody is pressing their face through the wall, a planter, place a light bulb behind it, use it to paint your own face through the holes, use it to stamp makeup onto your face. Also, Chris should ask his wife, the artist, for ideas.
What UK postcode has the highest Scrabble value? Does this change if you include the actual digits in the postcode?
Matt tells some postcode related anecdotes. Compared to other countries, UK postcodes are very detailed. They include both letters and numbers. Technically, there are enough postcodes that you could have a postcode for your cupboard.
Matt downloaded all UK postcodes and wrote some Python code to compute their Scrabble values. Of the postcodes with the maximum value of 35 points (ignoring digits), WC1X 9QZ in London is Matt's favourite. If you include digits individually, BN99 8ZZ and EX39 9ZZ are tied for 50 points. If you combine the digits, BN99 8ZZ wins with 131 points. Using 1337-speak (i.e. swapping numbers into their corresponding characters), EH22 2QQ and EH22 2QZ are tied on 55 points.
A "d1ng" from Matt
A listener suggests having kids, and a second listener with night shifts suggests biphasic instead of monophasic sleep: Sleep a shorter time during the night, then take a nap in the middle of your day, and finally go to sleep at the new time.
Lois is dinging the Pyrenees-to-Alps answer, which seems impressively long compared to the others.
The longest ding the hosts have ever seen
Answers by 128 people are in. Most of them have seen a penguin, but only 15% have seen one outside a zoo. There is a tie between the two fan-favourite problems, which are 017-2 and 021-1. 019-2 is in third place. Matt again did not provide a drop-down menu, and Bec mentions they need a wiki that explains all problems [Editor's note: Well...].
One feedback from the listener survey 027 (note) was that a lot of people want more episodes. Once the Patreon hits pi hundred subscribers, Matt and Bec will attempt to do 2 episodes per month.
It is not Bec's card.
The podcast has hit its Patreon goal and thus, episodes will now be more frequent. Because of this, there'll only be one big problem per episode, and one smaller dinglet/wingding.
This episode is being recorded one day after Two's Day Tuesday. Matt is still calming down from the excitement. Matt talks about his Two's Day Tuesday video, which was actually released on time. In just over 11 years, there'll bee Three's Day Thursday on 2033-03-03.
Bec watched Moneyball with Gavin on Two's Day Tuesday. She complains that there was too much sport and not enough maths. At 22:22, she paused the movie to tweet about Two's Day Tuesday.
The second Horror Heights book, "Now LiveScreaming", is finished, copy editing and all. Ever since, Bec's been in a great mood.
Assuming the signal was strong enough, what would happen if you tried to use a GPS satnav on the moon?
GPS satellites constantly yell the time into space. The signal travels with light speed, so you can calculate your distance to the satellite based on the delay. In n dimensions, you need at least n+1 satellites. A GPS receiver needs to know its location in 4D spacetime, so it needs 5 satellites (though 4 satellites can suffice if you assume you're on Earth). If you've got enough satellites, in theory you can find your position anywhere in space.
However, your satnav might still not work on the moon because the satellites are all very close together from your perspective, so your position estimate is very inaccurate. Matt suspects it wouldn't even reliably place you on the moon.
However, your satnav would refuse to work anyways. To avoid it being used in missiles, it will stop working if it moves faster than 1000 knots (1852 km/h) or if it is more than 18 km above sea level. Some manufacturers see this constraint as a logical "and" and some as a logical "or" though. If you get a manufacturer that views it as "and", in theory you would be just 100 km/h inside the speed limit relative to the surface of the Earth, but due to the inaccuracies, it will probably not work anyways.
A combination Bec and Beardyman ding
The poser enjoys a podcast with a running joke that involves one host asking the other "Is this your card?". They've lost track of why it's a running joke, how it started, why it's funny. They're too afraid to ask the hosts to explain the joke (at least directly) because they think it might ruin it.
Bec can't remember, neither can Matt. Bec argues that it is not a joke, and that Matt is actually trying to find Bec's card. [Editor's note: It originates from 018-3.] They request listener assistance to solve this problem.
Dave Lacompte [Editor's Note: Spelling likely incorrect] asks: If Pudding can run 9 km a day, how long would it take Pudding to reach the edge of the solar system? This is not a trick question.
Sleepy has renamed themselves Awakey. They are amazed at how thoroughly Bec has answered their question. They took Bec's advice and are changing their sleep schedule incrementally. They also bought a sunrise alarm clock. They say the most important thing is they've stopped stressing about it, and they're a lot less mad at themselves. This has made their life better.
Awakey considers it solved. A combination Matt and Beardyman ding.
It is not Bec's card. Matt drew the card from the wrong deck. Matt and Bec narrate an outro.
Bec and Matt are going to do their first recording in front of a live audience at bluedot festival. They will be there at 2022-07-22, pi approximation day. If you're in the audience, mention it when you submit a problem via the Problem Posing Page.
2022-03-14 is pi day. At the time of recording, Matt has just gotten back from Houghton-le-Spring, where William Shanks, who calculated pi to the most digits by hand, lived. There, Matt and a group of 30 people tried to calculate 100 digits of pi by hand. They got only the first 11 digits correct. The full video is up on Matt's YouTube channel. Fun fact: William Shanks' gravestone was bulldozed in the 1970s and his grave lost.
While they were grocery shopping, they noticed that there were some words that may freely be used on products whereas others can only be used on specific ones. In Germany, "premium" can be used freely whereas the word for "chocolate" can only be used on specific products. They'd like to know more examples which are or are not reserved on food products.
Bec spoke to a lot of people to solve this problem. She even took a course and got a certificate. All of her research was limited to the UK. Mislabeling your groceries is a food crime.
Bec explains a bunch of rules and examples, including chocolate and milk vs oat milk. There were apparently court cases against Froot Loops and Cap'n Crunch Crunch Berries for suggesting that they contain fruit. Quite a lot of super markets got in trouble because of their in-house brand names. Bec explains the differences between fruit juice and nectar. Bec explains the difference between natural mineral water, spring water, and plain bottled water. Jam apparently has a lot of rules. Finally, barn eggs only require 15 cm perch space per hen and only 1 m² of floor space per 9 chickens.
A preemptive free-range ding from Matt (with Beardyman undertones)
How much of a public servant's salary is paid by their own taxes?
Matt, having been a teacher, uses teaching salaries for his calculations. Roughly 0.0000006% of the UK government spending came from a single teacher's pay. Over a year, 0.02 pence of the teacher's salary comes from their own salary. Almost exactly, all the tax paid by all parents from a teacher's class is one penny of your annual salary.
0.02 of Bec's ding
Jack notes: The UK has a referencing system for every property, including individual flats/post boxes/structures, even Stonehenge. The UK referencing system is called the UPRN (Universal Property Reference Number). They can be up to 12 digits long. And unlike the postcode data set, which is owned by Royal Mail, the dataset is open data, licensed under the Open Government License.
Jono [Editor's note: Spelling likely incorrect] notes that a lot of Matt's winning options were illegal because there's only one Q and one Z. Matt only upheld the 7 tile limit. Matt accepts that he is wrong and deserves an unding (a "gnid"?).
Ken Floor got a shoutout for finishing their problem submission with "Best wishes, warmest dings". They were apparently trying to reopen the view distance problem.
Two more reviews are read aloud by Matt and Bec.
Matt presents multiple cards to Bec, none of which are her card.
Bec reads a review aloud titled "Bec Hill is incredible and the maths dude isn't too shabby either".
Bec was unable to join Matt and his wife at an event she invited them to. Instead, she got covid from her husband. The event was the launch event for a new season of reality TV show "Below Deck Down Under", where they follow the crew and rich people on super yachts in Australia. Matt ate a lot of cheese and Vegemite on toast, and he stole Bec a goodie bag.
So I was driving in my car today and had the following thought: What are the odds of having the same child twice? Not twins! Giving birth to a child, getting pregnant, then having the exact same child again by the same parents. It's infinitesimal, but how much compared to other infinitesimally unlikely occurrences?
A human cell has 23 pairs of chromosomes, for redundancy. When the body makes a reproductive cell (sperm/egg), only one of each pair is chosen. This makes for 2²³ = 8'388'608 possible options per parent, or 70 trillion possible children. In other words, the second child has a one-in-70-trillion chance of being the same as the first.
However, biology is a lot more complicated and there's actually a lot more combinations. Including some of those effects, there's 3 * 10¹⁶⁶ possible options for a reproductive cell starting with an XX configuration and 2*^0¹⁶⁰ starting with an XY configuration. The number of combinations for a single child has over 300 digits.
The probability of having a child and then another identical child is the equivalent of picking a single proton from the entire observable universe, mixing it back in, and randomly picking it again, four times in total. In short, it's not going to happen. It's slimpossible (there's an infinitesimally small chance, but it's practically impossible).
A "from my angle, I'm giving it a ding" from Bec (combined with a Beardyman ding)
Are there more wheels or doors in the world?
Both Matt and Bec came to the conclusion "doors".
A "ding" by Bec and a "ding ding ding" by Matt
APS is the first podcast Eva listens to regularly, and they really like the format. They want to listen to more, however they don't know how to find more good ones. Thus, they ask for recommendations.
Bec recommends A Podcast Of Unnecessary Detail (featuring Matt), Science Vs, Mathematical Objects, Reply All, Darknet Diaries, The Dream Factory.
The Dream Factory talks about hypothetical movies with pun titles. Matt spontaneously comes up with "Fast & Spurious", which Bec promises to send in to the podcast.
A combined Matt and Beardyman ding
Due to Bec being filled with phlegm, the answer will be delayed by one episode.
Dennis replied "Wow Bec, you went so far to answer my question. Congrats on your certification! Thanks a lot for it. You definitely get an un-gnid-able ding."
Chris asked whether counterfeiting a food naming certificate counts as a food crime.
An un-gnid-able ding by Dennis, combined with a Beardyman ding
Several people wrote in that it came from problem 018-3. One person, Red, wrote down the time and a transcript. Instead of cutting in the section of the recording, Bec and Matt read the transcript as a sort of old-timey audio play (Matt is playing Bec, and Bec is playing Matt).
Matt presents three cards to Bec, one of which is her card.
Bec is covid-free again, and filming on Makeaway Takeaway Season 2 will start next week.
Matt's show Humble Pi, which was canceled due to covid, but now he's re-booked a small number of shows to remember it and then film it. There might be lasers, courtesy of Seb Lee-Delisle.
Bec mentions Horror-Heights-related shows she's doing at a similar time, at Nine Lessons and Carols for Curious People.
Why are aspect ratios all whack? [The poser rambles on for a while.]
It's almost like different people making different things make different decisions. Bec asks Tom Salinsky onto the podcast to explain why movie aspect ratios are whack. Tom explains that things used to be made of stuff. Originally, things were a mess, but when sound came along, frame rates and aspect ratios were standardized by the Academy to roughly 4:3. Once TV came along, movies became wider. Showing movies on devices with different aspect ratio comes with a whole host of issues. Thanks to Dr. Kerns H. Powers, TVs (and other devices) now have a 16:9 aspect ratio. However, nowadays 2:1 is becoming more popular. Matt complains that there are two different 4K resolutions. Some films switch between different aspect ratios, which Matt is always excited about.
A "I think this — at least from where I'm standing — you've just given us a good ol' ding." from Bec, combined with a Beardyman ding
I got a missed call from a mobile number earlier today, but when I rang it up, I was informed the number had been disconnected. This got me thinking about how many mobile phone numbers there are. How do the Australian numbers compare to the UK and the US, and would we ever run out?
Matt tells a related anecdote about his teacher days. There are 100'000'000 possible mobile phone numbers in Australia, or roughly four per person. In the UK, there's 1'000'000'000 numbers, or roughly 15 per person. In the US and Canada combined, there's 6'400'000'000 numbers, or roughly 17 per person. Matt thinks there should just be a few more digits and there should be a check digit.
Kids nowadays don't remember their parent's phone numbers, Bec doesn't know her husband's. Matt knows three phone numbers by heart: His own, his wife's, and some friend's parent's house from the 90s. Matt tells another anecdote related to recycled phone numbers and the UFC.
There was some uncertainty where the edge of the solar system is. Professor Lucie Green (Matt's wife), a solar scientist, says that the edge is the Heliopause, which sits about 18 billion km away. The answer is roughly 2 billion days, or 5.5 million years. Matt will accept anything between 3 and 10 million years. Among the correct solutions are Dexter and Ivy with a YouTube video.
A lot of people were upset at the glib answer in the previous episode. Matt and Bec have re-done their calculations and both got wheels.
Someone from within the US food testing industry said that until 2016, the government technically couldn't stop companies selling contaminated food, only fine it.
Tom shows Bec a card, but it is not her card.
Matt has hit 1 million subscribers on YouTube. Bec has not brought anything to celebrate.
For Makeaway Takeaway, they filmed in a big house in Manchester. For legal reasons, someone (Bec) has to say in the house over night. While there, she did some writing for her Horror Heights series, when suddenly she heard some footsteps. Scary hijinks ensue, but you need to listen to the episode (it's worth it).
How many molehills would you need to make a mountain out of them?
Matt went and found a molehill (frustrum-shaped), which he then measured. A mountain needs to be at least 1000 ft (304.8 m) to be considered a mountain and not a hill. To compute the volume, Matt takes into accounnt the angle of repose, i.e. how the dirt slumps. Bec notes the problem's similarity to problem 011-2. In total, you need 3'060'370'873 molehills to make a mountain.
As a Hill, Bec approves and gives this problem a ding.
How can one make friends after adulthood? It's weird not being able to just hang out and talk about stuff. How can one make new friends and not just adult acquaintances?
Bec doesn't have an acquaintance setting, she is always in friend mode. She suggests just forcing yourself on people (not physically though). If you go in with the expectation that you will be friends, most people won't resist it. She also suggests repeating someone's name when talking to someone, to remember it better. Bec made a lot more friends when she started putting herself out there and doing things on her own (e.g. signing up for clubs and sports activities). Bec suggests improv clubs. You also need to be proactive and make plans, things won't happen on their own. Matt's strategy is stealing friends from other friends, though this also requires being proactive. Bec recommends common interest groups for things you're passionate about.
Bec tries to start #friendding to share friend advice and stories.
When Matt was talking about discounting every lottery ticket containing the number 7, Matt said it was over 0.5 million discounted tickets. Peter Rowlett checked and realized it was actually 4.5 million tickets. Matt had just read the wrong number from his spreadsheet, the remaining numbers and working out were correct.
A lot of people wrote in to complain about "no bacteria in food". However, just after saying "no bacteria", Matt and Bec said "except the good bacteria", but Lauren cut it out of the episode.
The Dream Factory were very impressed with Matt's pun. What they didn't know was that Matt and Bec sat there for quite a while thinking of pun movie titles, but it was cut out of the episode by Lauren.
While Matt's go-to film franchise is Fast & Furious, Bec's is Dunston Checks In. Matt doesn't believe Bec's claim that the listeners know this movie, so they do a Twitter poll.
"Sometimes the edit taketh, and sometimes the edit giveth, but it all balances out" — Matt
Matt realizes he didn't bring his cards from home, so he searches for and finds them while Bec does the credits. It is not Bec's card.
Bec's second Horror Heights book "Now LiveScreaming" has come out. Matt makes a cameo as the first message in a stream chat room. Some of Bec and Matt's book-related discussions were had around the fire pit from episode 012 (update).
Matt has been sent a tensegrity fire pit built by a fan, which now replaces his barbecue with the legs taken off (yes, he paid for it). He's escaped the fire pit cycle. This evening will be the inaugural fire; Bec has brought marshmallows.
Can one produce less smelling or even well smelling farts by eating or drinking a certain food?
Bec is uniquely qualified because she has IBS and the sense of humour to match. High protein foods cause smelly farts, but that was not enough for Bec. She contacted experts Dr. CK Yao and Dr. Jessica Biesiekierski, the latter of which recorded a voice message with lots of detail and food suggestions for both nicer and worse smells.
Bec has also found a french fart pill (Pilule Pet) which is meant to make your farts smell like roses. Of course Bec ordered some. Jessica is sceptical, but suggested charcoal fart pads. The fart pill ingredients list was turned into a parody song by Gareth Turkington.
A "ding" by Matt and a raspberry by Bec, even with the pill test results still pending
When does a computer become a supercomputer, and do publicly purchaseable personal computers surpass the capabilities of the first/early supercomputers? If so, how much would it cost?
A supercomputer is just a very powerful normal computer. Actually, supercomputers are a lot of processors joined together for one or more big tasks. Matt got to walk around inside two supercomputers.
Supercomputers are measured in floating point operations per second (FLOPS). The iPhone 12 can do roughly 10¹⁰ FLOPS, an M1 Mac's GPU has 10¹² FLOPS, while current top supercomputers can do 10¹⁷ FLOPS. In the past, Moore's law predicts computers become twice as powerful every two years (though it has to be taken with a grain of salt), so in 50 years, a phone should have the equivalent power to a modern-day supercomputer. Looking into the past, the old Cray supercomputers were doing around 10⁸ FLOPS, or roughly 1% of a modern-day iPhone.
A "dinglet" by Bec
Listener Matthew requests: "I think you need a website/wiki page so that we can easily see the previous questions asked and their solutions. There, you could also include links to your sources, or the spreadsheet/code Matt makes for certain problems, as well as pictures." Matt and Bec promise to help with a wiki/definitive list, e.g. by providing assets and code, and request anyone undertaking such a project to get in touch.
Such a wiki was previously requested in episode 013 (note) and in episode 027 (note).
It is not Bec's card.
The £5K T-shirt is going up for auction, as part of a private exhibition (though the auction will be public). The goal is to get another £5K for WaterAid.
Bec is recording from her cupboard, while Matt is recording in Perth, the cupboard of Australia.
On his way to Perth in Australia, his flight stopped at Darwin, a Matt First™. More flight anecdotes follow, and Bec philosophizes about travel and holidays.
The day the second Horror Heights book "Now LiveScreaming" came out, Bec was asked to do a gig in Glasgow, where she rode a tiny horse, beat a 16 year old boy, and high-fived a bunch of kids by accident. Matt has a running joke with James Grime involving high fives and handshakes. Matt and Bec discuss types of awkward high fives, and invite listeners to share theirs.
How many n-th cousins and how many times removed are you from the common harbour seal?
Bec complains about the family tree of Back to the Future. Matt explains how the cousin naming scheme works: You first need to find the nearest common ancestor of yourself and the cousin you want to locate. You and the cousin both have a distance (measured in generations) to said ancestor. The shorter distance minus one becomes the degree n of the cousin (n-th cousin), and the absolute difference between the distance becomes the degree m of removal (n-th cousin m times removed).
Matt tracks down the closest common ancestor, which was 82 million years ago. He then estimates how many generations lie between it and both the seals (21 million generations) and humans (27 million generations). We are 21 millionth cousins, 6 million times removed.
Bec meanwhile found a McFly family tree. Marty McFly's dad is probably 3rd cousins with his wife, which Bec assumes to be legal.
Darren has written ⅓ of a novel but doesn't know if it's bad or worth completing. How can they find out whether or not it's bad without letting anyone they know read it or putting it on the internet for everyone to read?
It's bad because it's not completed. Whether to complete it is a personal choice. Writing a book is only half the effort (or even less), the rest of the effort is revising and improving it. Also, even if the start is good, the rest of the novel may be bad. Bec recommends the book "On Writing" by Stephen King. Book titles are a lot like cats.
Bec's voice cuts off just after she starts saying something.
Vax Headroom points out that Matt made a maths mistake: Matt says that 4096 is 2¹⁴ while it is 2¹². The sound snippet in question is reviewed and Matt is caught red-handed.
Vax Headroom knows it's 2¹² because a 12 bit analog-to-digital converter has a max value of 4095 and they use them all the time in the software they write to control space craft.
Frank asks whether Matt knew that "Lutin Malin" is French for "clever gnome" before describing him as looking a bit like a gnome. Matt did not know that.
Since Matt went to Australia, the fart pills arrived. Bec has been taking them. Her farts do not smell of roses, but they have become less gassy and less bad. She'll keep taking them in the hope of a more conclusive result.
Ones of people (3 people) have offered to put together a wiki. They will coordinate with Matt and Bec. In a future episode, there might be a call for extra volunteers.
The results of the poll are in. 44% chose "Nah, no idea" while 42% chose "Yes, totally remember it".
Matt forgot to bring his cards to Australia, so he ran down to the shops and bought a deck. He shows Bec 8 cards, one of which is her card.
Matt is still recording from Australia, while Bec is still in her cupboard in London.
Bec has been doing some voice-overs for the kangaroo in an exercise program for the Yoto player. She also made chicken noises.
One of the highlights of his trip to Australia was buying a $1 pair of shorts. They're probably haunted.
If the moon was made of cheese, how long would it take for the people of Earth to consume it entirely? Assuming people will consume cheese at the same rate as now, there's no issue with transporting the cheese, and the moon is by volume, not mass.
Matt has never understood the "the moon is cheese" joke. There's no proof that anybody ever seriously believed it, but it appears in folklore. The most common cheese around the time the story originated would be feta.
Bec computes the amount of cheese the moon would be, and uses the UK's cheese consumption, but focused entirely onto moon feta and scaled up onto the entire world. In total, it would take us roughly 310 billion years to eat the moon, though the sun might fondue it before we finish.
If instead we all ate as much cheese as possible, and using the stomach capacity from problem 002-1, the moon would be gone in only 4 billion years. This fits nicely within the remaining life time of the solar system of 5 billion years.
A big old cheesy ding from Matt, combined with a Beardyman ding
I heard somebody say today that if you shot a bullet and dropped a bullet at the same time, they would hit the ground at the same time. I generally agree with this, but I have a problem: If the bullet travels in a straight line over a long enough distance, I would think the curvature of the Earth comes into it. The Earth falls away, meaning the bullet would have to fall further than the one just dropped. So my problem is: How much does the Earth drop away, and how much longer does the bullet take to hit the ground because of it?
Assuming you're shooting the bullet perfectly horizontally, and assuming there is no air, and assuming that the earth is flat, Jay is correct in that they'd both hit the ground at the same time. Bec diverts the topic onto the Matrix movies.
The idea of bullets going faster than the Earth drops away is exactly how satellites stay in orbit. If you dug a hole all the way through the Earth, the dropped bullet would arrive at the other side of the Earth at exactly the same time as the shot bullet, so the same principle still works. The max speed of the dropped bullet is exactly the same speed as the shot bullet. Bec demands Matt's working out; he gladly obliges.
Given any planet of any size, and any arbitrary hole through it, as long as it has the density of the Earth, a dropped object will always take 42 minutes to reach the other side of the hole.
A "I think that's a ding" by Bec
Matt and Bec read 3 more reviews aloud, with a few in-jokes.
Matt shows Bec 4 cards, none of which are her card.
Matt is back from Australia, and the two hosts are recording in the office again. Lauren is not there because she has covid.
Pi has been calculated to 100 trillion digits by a Google developer who has already held the record once in the past. The digits take 515 TB of storage, and the calculations took 157 days, 23 hours, 31 minutes, 7.651 seconds.
The art exhibition happened, but the T-shirt did not sell. The minimum bet was £5K. Bec also exhibited and sold some more pun-based art pieces in the exhibition.
Is there a way to number a menu where giving the total will result in a correct order?
There is no perfect system that scales arbitrarily. If you cap the number of individual dishes per order, you can number your dishes 1, 10, 100 and so on (other bases are also available), but this feels a bit like cheating. Matt gives Bec a menu and Bec orders from it.
Another approach might be using complex numbers, but Matt couldn't make it work. Matt suspects there must be some mathematical objects where you can reverse the addition losslessly. Matt asks listeners for any such objects.
Finally, if you use multiplication, you can just give each item a different prime number and exploit prime number decomposition. If Matt was running a café, he'd call it "The Rows and Column" and he'd use punch cards for orders.
Bec only gives this a half ding, or rather, a single Law & Order "dung".
When there is somebody behind you when you open the door, what is the polite distance to wait for someone, and what is the creepy distance to wait for someone?
If you go into a building and it isn't very clear that the other person wants to go in as well, don't hold it open. It depends on how they're approaching the door, and if they do a little skip, that's a universal sign they want to go in. Maybe tie your shoelaces to buy some time.
If you're coming out of a room or building, use two lengths of the other person as the cutoff. However, if the person can't easily open the door (e.g. holding lots of stuff), use eye contact instead.
If the door is a security door, don't hold the door open for anyone unless it's clear they also belong. Maybe even pull the door closed if it's unclear. This is also how you can infiltrate high security places.
If the door is an elevator door, if you're alone, you hold it open. If there's multiple people, it's a space/capacity tradeoff. In a full elevator, don't hold it open. Matt suggests pretending to press the doors open button, though Bec notes it just looks like you're pressing the doors close button.
Revolving and automated doors don't require any action. Drawbridges might not count as doors. ISS air locks might also require special handling.
If you're a creepy person, any distance is the creepy distance. Don't hold doors open and stop being creepy. Otherwise, if you'd use the door anyways and the person you're holding it for is aware of you, it's not really creepy. When in doubt, just let it close.
The first ever live recording of A Problem Squared will happen at bluedot festival, which happens from 2022-07-21 to 2022-07-24. Until then, listeners with problems for a live audience are encouraged to enter them in the Problem Posing Page.
People wrote in regarding how falling through the Earth would feel. On Twitter, @murkee said "Physicist here, it'd be freefall all the way." They've also pointed out the Earth's density is not uniform. Someone else pointed out that while falling, there'll be a gravity gradient over your body, but Matt suspects it won't be noticeable. Bec suspects that in any scenario, you'd hit the wall and hurt yourself.
In an episode of the bonus podcast I'm A Wizard, the question came up whether Australia is the only country where some parts do daylight savings and some don't. Marcel wrote in on the Problem Posing Page to note that Canada has the same problem.
Matt shows Bec the four of spades, which is her card! Matt brings party bag twisties to celebrate. The card will be sold on Ebay for £5K.
Bec did the show Werewolf: Live in Covent Garden, where she met Tom and Owen from Mr Thing. On the latter show, Matt filled in for the corpse a few times. After her show, Bec joined the Mr Thing crew for a Tequila, some beers, and some Prosecco. She also played some weird instruments.
Matt ordered some electronics. However, when picking it up, he forgot his photo ID. Nevertheless, the people at the pickup did everything they could to give him his wares. Matt wonders when it would be socially acceptable to just ask them to google him. [Editor's note: The ending to the story is worth it.]
When does a high five become a low five? Does it depend on the height of the hands or the direction the fingers are pointing? Can one person be high fiving and the other low fiving in the same high-low five?
Bec posits that it's the orientation of the hand that determines the height of the five. In a normal high five, the palms are vertical, whereas for a low five or an "up high" five, the hands are horizontal. Matt challenges Bec with increasingly complex high five variants. If you're lying on tne floor, you count as a child. The executor of the five names the high.
A high ding from Matt (combined with a Beardyman ding), and a low ding from behind from Bec
We all know about seven segment displays, which can display any digit from 0 to 9, but what is the minimum number of segments that could display readable digits? For instance, is there a configuration of six segments which could be arranged so as to produce readable digits?
Matt explains to Bec what a seven segment display is. The earliest use of the classic seven segment displays is 1903 (Matt dug out the patent, Nr. 1126641).
Matt has designed a six segment display, which consists of a diamond shape with a horizontal line and a vertical line, which manages to display all 10 digits. A 3 segment display is impossible because there are only 8 different combinations. Matt tried to design a 4 segment display, but it doesn't quite work.
Listeners are encouraged to voice their opinion or give it a go themselves.
A tentative "ding?" by Bec
@platinum_west on Twitter said that before the invention of refrigeration and food dyes, cheese was not an orange rectangle, but round and off-white.
@yellingatsocker [Editor's note: I could not find the account] would like to put forth that Mimolette is the most moon-like cheese.
On instagram, stephabee [Editor's note: There are lots of different accounts with similar names] (Dexter's legal guardian) wants to know if the moon would have a cheese fondue core. Matt calls his wife Lucie Green, who suspects it would not be hot in the center, though she is unsure. If it was hot, there would be plate tectonics, which we don't observe.
Bec and Matt remind the listeners of the bluedot live recording, and to send in their problems (ideally not via tweet).
Matt already knows Bec's card. There is an awkward moment as the two hosts are in-between post credits gags.
Matt and Bec talk about watching how many videos of YouTube friends is too much watching. Matt made a Drake meme video about the values of the sin function, and explains the joke.
Studio filming for Makeaway Takeaway filming is done, though on-location shooting is still left. Bec invited James (the best friend of her brother Mike from problem 006-1) and Sophie from problem 003-2 to the studio. The two are now married.
James and Sophie play a game called "tiny emotions" where they make a subtle expression and the other has to guess what it is.
How many guesses can you do in Wordle before you have to repeat letters? Obviously, after 5 words you'd have to, but is it possible to guess 5 actual words with 5 unique letters?
Matt pulled out his big text file of words, filtered it, and wrote some shitty Python code. In particular, he took all 5 letter words without duplicate letters, removed anagrams, joined them into pairs with 10 unique characters, joined those into quadruplets with 20 unique characters, and finally joined them up with the original word list into quintuplets with 25 unique characters.
The code ran for over a month, and then spit out 528 combinations, 470 of which all contain the word fldxt (an abbreviation for fluid extract). Bec disapproves of abbreviations. The solution with the most popular words (according to Google) is vibex, glyph, muntz, dwarf, jocks (or fjord, wacks).
The original Wordle contained a list of solution words, and a second bigger list of all acceptable guess words. Only exactly one of Matt's combinations is fully contained in the Wordle guess list: Fjord, gucks, nymph, vibex, waltz. Matt will make a video about this.
A "dings" by Bec (and a Beardyman ding)
Jacob has been taking improv classes and it was fun. He continues: However, I've found that while I enjoy doing structured short-form scenes, I have a hard time making myself step out on stage in unstructured, long-form shows. I feel like I get caught up in my own head, which makes me hesitate for long enough that other people have already stepped out to do the scene. How do I get myself to do more scenes in shows and not get stuck in line?
Bec notes that Jacob is a higher level (level 3) than Bec (level 1), which means she hasn't done unstructured stuff yet either. Bec notes that this problem isn't restricted to improv, but useful in life in general. Bec plays advice from some professional improvisers.
Alex Holland from The Free Association tells Jacob to give himself permission not to be funny and to not worry about the audience. Matt's motto: "They can't all be winners."
David Reed from The Penny Dreadfuls says the audience is watching you being brave in the face of potential failure. You're still brave even if you fail. Bec notes the audience wants you to do well. Matt's motto: "Give it a go!"
Rachel Parris from The Mash Report and Austentatious says that it's fine to be nervous, and that you don't need a good idea coming onto the stage. Trust your partner and the things around you to give you an idea. Matt's motto: "If you're not nervous, you're doing something wrong."
Josie Lawrence from Whose Line Is It Anyway recommends freeing your mind, going with the flow, throwing yourself into the lake. You won't sink. If you're floundering, someone else will help you, it's a team effort.
A transferrable ding from Matt (with a Beardyman ding)
Some people say it's about the position of the finger tips: In a high five, they touch, in a "down low" they don't. Bec disagrees: In an "on the side", they are touching but it's not a high five.
Josh pointed out via the Problem Posing Page that the lunar core is 1330°C and 45 atmospheres of pressure. They're not sure what the cheese phase diagram would look like.
Bec's card was sold at auction for the WaterAid charity. The postage was £3.14 (picked by Matt) and the winning bid was £69. The card is now on its way to Singapore.
Everyone is making the joke about how many so-and-so do you need to change a lightbulb, but no one's asking it for real. But I wonder what it is: Are there places where you can't change a lightbulb as one person, because of its location or because of the shape of the bulb? What about spacecrafts, like the ISS? Does a single person change the light bulb on it? I am really tuned for what you may find out.
In 2016, they started changing all the fluorescent lights on the ISS for LED panels. Bec contacted the principal investigator in a study on lighting's effects on astronauts, Steven Lockley from Harvard, who confirmed the lights are still being changed. Because this inquiry was inconclusive, Bec contacted astronaut Tim Peake, who was there while the bulbs were being changed out.
There's a lighthouse in Florida that changes its own bulb. Bec contacted the Split Point lighthouse, who in 2015 changed their light bulbs for LEDS, which took two people. It also takes two people to change the light bulbs on top of an aerial tower. Changing the spotlights on the Eiffel Tower takes 43 technicians.
The largest light bulb might've been created for an art installation in Tulsa, Oklahoma. It took 50 people to install, but you can't change it because there's only one of it. It's powered by LEDs, which take only one person to change.
Eventually, Bec heard back from Tim Peake. While not a light bulb, a light assembly took only one person to change.
A ding by the audience
How big should my trebuchet be if I wanted to use it to throw projectiles faster than the speed of sound? Forget about the material problems here, assume that the machine itself would be able to cope. How far would it shoot? Assume ideal situation with no drag. Could we shoot into space? Would this trebuchet be the first environmentally friendly space force?
To go to space, you need to launch it at roughly 11'000 m/s, which is Mach 32 (32 times the speed of sound in air).
Since they couldn't bring a trebuchet, Matt brings on-stage a "kinetic energy demonstration device" consisting of two brooms and two 5 kg weights. Because the APS merch didn't arrive in time, they're launching bluedot and Numberphile T-shirts into the audience that Bec turned into APS merch.
To launch a shirt into space, you'd only need a 940 ton counterweight a metre off the ground. Whether this is environmentally friendly depends on where the energy to lift the counterweight came from.
A ding by the audience
Tomorrow, Matt will be signing copies of Bec's Horror Heights books, and Bec will be signing copies of Matt's Humble Pi book. They will also be selling T-shirts.
Bec tried to be a good person by doing the dishes. She left the hot water in the sink running for a good half an hour and properly flooded the entire kitchen.
Matt went to the European Robotics Foundation as light entertainment for nerds. He enjoys being out of his depth and desperately trying to follow along when maths nerds start talking.
Steve is engaged and the wedding will be in over a year. Similar to traditional gifts for positive wedding anniversaries, Steve now needs a gift for a negative wedding anniversary.
Bec denies getting distracted during, then explains Tibetan wedding traditions. The traditional gifts start in the mid to late 1800s in Germany. A bit later, the American National Retail Jewelers Association add more types of anniversaries. They change depending on who is trying to sell you something, though they're usually some material. Bec and Matt go through anniversaries in detail. On a semi-related note, Lucie and Matt celebrate their wedding anniversary every 500 days, and later this year will be the third anniversary of the podcast.
For the -1st anniversary, Bec suggests the opposite of diamonds, i.e. graphite (which, with a lot of pressure, will turn into diamonds). She has bought a block of drawing graphite and will send it to the pair. She also suggests ink as the 0th anniversary (i.e. wedding) gift.
A ding as a gift from Matt, on behalf of Steve and fiancee
How do I write a review for the podcast that helps you in any way if I do not have any Apple products? Google Podcast does not have this option, and I don't have an Apple ID.
Only 13.4% of listeners use Apple podcasts. 0.3% of people use Python requests, the 22nd most common way. The number 1 way people listen to the podcast is Spotify, so leave a rating there.
A Problem Squared on Spotify currently has a rating of 5.0 stars at 326 (edit: 327, Lauren voted live) reviews. A Podcast Of Unnecessary Detail has 4.9 stars at 399 reviews. No Such Thing As A Fish has 5.0 at 6.7k reviews.
A "I think we've well and truly dinged this problem" by Bec, combined with a Beardyman ding
After the episode, Bec got addicted to the problem as well. Listeners sent in their solutions. Some solutions didn't really count because lines crossed, or because people invented new symbols for numbers. Bec gives an honorable mention to Leo's 4 segment display, whose 4 looks like a 4.
Some people mentioned binary numbers and glorified lists. Some people mentioned what is essentially concatenating numbers. Some people mentioned matrices.
Finally, some people mentioned that you can't order an irrational number of dishes. If you assume all order quantities are rational, you can make all menu items irrational numbers, which is reversible. You can also use logarithms to turn the prime number product based solution from the original episode into an addition based solution. The only problem left is that you need to round the numbers or you can't write them down.
Finally, if you choose your irrational number very close to the price of the object, meaning the order number is also the price (up to rounding errors).
While Bec was cleaning up the cupboards from her flooded kitchen, she found a variety of snacks from around the world, which are stale Twisties alternatives. Bec tries one of them, but it isn't great.
After the bluedot festival, Matt and Lucie went to see a Björk performance. It didn't use enough lasers for Matt's taste.
The A Problem Squared merch to be used with the T-shirt trebuchet from problem 039-2 showed up. Matt sent half of it to Bec. One T-shirt design says "Name another podcast who launches their merchandise via trebuchet. I'll weight."
The packet also includes the official bluedot festival hoodie, which features both Björk and A Problem Squared (alongside many other acts).
After the bluedot festival, Bec was booked to read her book at Deer Shed festival. In the Q&A after the reading, a girl asked who took care of Pudding when Bec is away. Her dad apparently listened to A Problem Squared
Last weekend, Pudding has left us for the big week in the sky at age 2. There were no suspicious circumstances. Bec is unsure whether to continue with A Pudding Squared, but the segment will be suspended for a while. This episode is dedicated to Pudding, the unofficial mascot of the pudcast.
I, along with what I can only assume is everyone, dislike tables which wobble. Most of the time, you just shove a bit of anything under the leg, and you're all set. But what if you don't have a bit of anything? Given a four-legged table, can you always find a spot on a surface where the table will sit without wobbling? Or, put another way, does there exist a surface on which a table will always wobble?
There's the wobbly table problem in maths, which has been around for a while. The latest research says that given a rectangular table with same-height legs and a continuous surface with no angles greater than 35.26°, there will be a table configuration that is stable and does not wobble. A table with three legs never wobbles, bbut it might tip over more easily. In practice, Matt has never come across a wobbly table that he couldn't fix by rotating it. However, the theorem has not been fully proven, and the people behind the Mathologer YouTube channel are currently working on it.
The table problem proof uses the intermediate value theorem, which is intuitive to understand but hard to use rigorously. It states that if something moves continuously from one value to another, it must've moved through every value in-between at some point. Bec struggles to understand Matt's convoluted food-based examples.
A wobbling table on a discontinuous (e.g. tiled) floor may always wobble.
A "ding ding" by Bec, combined with a Beardyman ding
If you had to choose, which would be more effective for your dental hygiene: A toothbrush without toothpaste, or toothpaste without a toothbrush?
In the solution to problem 003-2, Bec learned that toothpaste exists mainly to assist our saliva. The effect only lasts for roughly 24 hours. The brush gets rid of the plaque and does the majority of the work. This means you should always choose the toothbrush over the toothpaste. Sophie, the podcast's resident dental expert, confirmed this answer.
Matt wants to know what you should do if you have no toothbrush. Bec guesses eating cheese is a good choice, due to calcium. The hosts pose this problem to the listeners.
A ding by Matt
@FrenchguyCh on Twitter suggests naming the wedding anniversaries after the periodic table of elements, and wishes Matt a happy oxygen anniversary. Matt suggests the -1st anniversary would be antimatter. Episode $040 came out on Bec's 6th wedding anniversary.
The original couple have confirmed that the answer absolutely 100% earned a ding, and thanked the hosts for the gift.
A negative ding from the soon-to-be married couple
People have given the podcast more reviews on Spotify. Episode $040 has only been released for a day, and APS has gone from 327 to 515 reviews, still at 5.0 stars. A Podcast Of Unnecessary Detail have gone from 400 to 464 reviews, and is still at 4.9 stars. No Such Thing As A Fish has gone up to 7.3k reviews.
Bec opens a packet of Chee.Toz, which she and Matt then try out. They are stale but taste good.
Bec was at Edinburgh Festival Fringe, but not as a performer. While there, she stayed with the guys from Mr Thing. One of them, Gus, gave Bec a grappling hook as a gift. It's like a big dangerous fidget toy
Matt went to Finland to a maths art conference called Bridges. One cool thing was about randomly generated knitting patterns.
Matt is hoping to extend the slinky staircase world record. For this purpose, he's looking for a set stairs without a landing and about 100 steps. While in Finland, he measured a candidate set of stairs. Another candidate set of stairs exists on Saint Helena, but it's hard to get to. Matt asks the listeners to send in candidates if they come across any. If anybody builds one, Matt promises to come there.
At what point does a plate become a bowl? They have a bowl that their family claims is a plate. A similar question has been asked a bit later by someone called Patrick.
[Editor's note: The problem starts with some editing mistakes.] Bec proposes the soup test: If it holds soup and you can scoop it out with a spoon, then it's a bowl. However, then she presents a soup plate. Matt proposes an area based test: Ignoring rims, if there's more slope area than flat area, it's a bowl. Matt proposes another test where a bowl's curvature must change while a plate consists of straight parts. Bec dismantles Matt's proposals using counter examples. Bec wil do a poll; the problem will stay undinged for now.
Bec did some etymology research: The word "plate" comes from plates of armour. The word "bowl" ultimately means "round".
Matt's code took 32 days on his laptop. Approximately one day later, Benjamin Paaßen sent in code that took 15 minutes. Benjamin built a graph of words with no common letters, and then used some graph theory to search it for K5 subgraphs. While that was happening, Neil Coffey wrote some Java code that took only 15 seconds. After the video released, a frenzy of solutions poured in. At the time of recording, the record is approximately 2 ms.
Benjamin downloaded and benchmarked all the solutions, analyzed them, and created a ranking. The single greatest improvement was storing words as numbers instead of sets, reminiscent of the approach from problem 036-1.
It also turns out that people first asked the same question, called the Jotto problem back then, in 1986. In 1996 it was revisited, and someone found the exact same solution as Matt did and published it in a paper.
People then adapted the code to incorporate words of any length to cover the alphabet in as few words as possible. They rediscovered the combination of words "blacksmith" and "gunpowdery", which cover 20 letters. They also discovered "showjumping" and "veldcraft" as a brand new such combination, with no letters in common. Matt proposes listeners come up with two words that sound like words with more than 20 letters in common and send them in. Matt and Bec will then assign meanings to those words.
Extra dings from Bec
Matt misses the "Is this your card" segment. Bec opens an already-open packet of stale NikNaks (from South Africa) that went off in May 2017. Matt smells (a very mild smell) and Bec tastes (flavour's not bad, very greasy). Listeners are encouraged to send fresh snacks.
Matt has made some mirror balls for Alex James at the Big Feastival. They were constructed in the cheese hub. The balls consist of 150 faces each and have handedness (chirality), and Matt built a left handed and a right handed version. This makes them mirror mirror balls. This all happened on a very dusty farm in the UK heat wave, so Matt's voice is a bit hoarse.
Bec went to the End of the Road festival in Dorset and did a Celebrity Pun Fair. She has built a puppet representing a celebrity, and is inviting listeners to guess who it is. Matt incorrectly guesses Coconut Shylester Stallone.
In Busted's 2002 hit "Year 3000", they proclaim that "your great-great-great granddaughter is pretty fine". Assuming technological advances in keeping humans alive (they live underwater now after all), what is the youngest this great-great-great granddaughter could be with just 5 generations separating you in the year 2002 and her in the year 3000?
Matt and Bec start by analyzing the lyrics of the song in detail. For Busted's 7th album to come out near the year 3000, each stasis in-between reforming needs to be 9.4373 times longer than the previous one.
Using Matt's working out from problem 034-1 and with some additional research, Matt computes that there are 37.1 generations between the years 2002 and 3000. For the great-great-great granddaughter to exist, the generational gap needs to increase by a factor of 2.1 each generation.
A ding by Bec
Why do boys have nipples?
Because all embryos are female in the early stages. They differentiate only after a few weeks. Having nipples is not disadvantageous, so we haven't lost our vestigial nipples.
A "ding ding" from Matt, one ding per nipple
A carrot and some cheese came in at 25.1%, an apple got 16.7%, and celery came in at 33.1%. Bec sent the poll results to Doctor Sophie (in the UK dentists are not doctors, while in Australia, dentists have to get a doctor of dentistry or dental surgery, so Sophie is actually a doctor). Sophie says the correct answer is cheese, as it helps with remineralization. The second place is celery.
Very soon after this episode airs, Matt and Bec are going to New York City. Matt and friends are doing An Evening Of Unnecessary Detail. Bec is doing a spot in the show. The profits go to WaterAid.
While already there, Matt and Bec will record a special New York A Problem Squared episode. Listeners are encouraged to send in New York related problems.
Bec is out of out of date Twisties alternatives. She proposes searching for a US Twisties alternative in NY next episode. Listeners are encouraged to send in suggestions.
Matt and Bec will be leaving New York the day this episode releases. They will have had a good time.
Bec went to the Edinburgh Fringe — again. Still not as a performer. Bec and a friend danced, and then DJed at 03:00 in the morning (because of course she knew the people at the venue). Since Bec has been bitten by the DJ bug, she now needs a DJ name. Some options are DJ Be Chill, DJ Dex Hill. Listeners are encouraged to send their own suggestions. Matt's DJ name would be Algo Rhythm. If they DJ together, they could be Bananas in DJamas.
In A Podcast Of Unnecessary Detail, Matt mentioned that he wants to see the new sewers of London. Someone working for the sewers heard that, and thus Matt got a tour of the Blackfriars Tideway site, though he did not get to go into the pipes. However, he did get to stand on top of a crapnado, a poop vortex (though it was inactive since the sewerage system was not yet finished). He still wants to see the old Bazalgette sewers, and asks the listeners for help.
Ben has been inspired by Bec's grappling hook chat in episode 042 (news). Their issue is that while they'd like to be Batman, they're not a wealthy business person. What one utility could they strap to their belt that would help them stop the most crime (ideally under £100)?
During the problem statement, Matt and Bec discuss the technicalities of Batman's merch. They're also wearing their DING merch shirts.
Bec starts by working out the most common crimes (in the UK). They are, in order, fraud (including scams), theft, computer misuse, violence, and vehicle offenses. Bec asked in a tweet about people who have been scammed, and talks about a few of the stories from the replies.
Bec's first solution would be common sense, but it's not technically stopping the crime. To figure out why people do crimes, she then asked people whether they ever committed a crime, and got a few good replies. She also read some papers. There's lots of factors, e.g. because the benefits outweigh the costs, or because people feel compelled to do so.
After all that, and reading a book, Bec came to the conclusion that we need hope in order to overcome the apathy of "there's nothing you can do" and to change our society. Thus, you need an item that induces hope in others. She is unsure what item that should be (a badge? a buckle?), and requests item ideas from listeners. Matt also suggests donating the £100.
What is the speed of smell?
Matt only looks at the time it takes the smell to get to the nose since biology is a mess. Instead of going into the theory of diffusion and brownian motion, Matt conducts an experiment: Matt puts limited edition artificial intelligence Lynx deodorant in a nonempty subset of his three solo cups, seals them with cling film, numbers them and shuffles them. Bett is one meter away from each cup when it is pierced, and Matt measures the time until they each smell it. Lots of heavy breathing ensues. According to the data, Bec's speed of smell is 2.3 cm/s (or 1.4 m/min) and Matt's is 2.5 cm/s (or 1.5 m/min). In conclusion, the speed of smell in Matt's office is 0.09 km/h.
A ding from Bec, combined with a Beardyman ding
A lot of people have sent in their opinions. Marcel said the solution was clearly the same as the solution to problem 011-3. Matt initially disagrees, but then agrees, but then disagrees again. L00natic proposes that if you put something on it, it's a plate, and if you put something in it, it's a bowl. They also suggest a bonus category of "cup". Nicole on Patreon says the dish in the cupboard photo from last episode was a plate for catching messy good. However, Bec has used it for soup in the past. Another patron say that in Dutch, it's just called a deep plate.
The poll results are in: Surface curves with rim got 19.9%, surface curves with no rim got 29.7%, and the spoon test got 50.4%.
Several people mentioned the steps on artificial ski slopes, or steps in castles. The winning suggestion is the Lion's Mound monument in Belgium with 226 fairly regular and steep steps. Matt now needs an eye witness account from these steps. Bec might be there soon, but listeners nearby that could help should get in touch.
Someone else got in touch with a company that can make custom slinkys. Matt is excited.
Bec has found a pack of Wotsits Crunchy, and they're in date! They smell like Lynx AI, as does everything in the room. Bec and Matt both like them.
Matt went to Disney World, where he met Alan (the intern from Captain Disillusion). Matt and Bec talk a bit about differen kinds of Disney theme parks and rides.
Matt and Bec are recording this episode in a studio in New York, with sound engineer Jody.
Bec was staying in Italy in Castrovillari with friends. Her friend's favourite reason for living there was billboard mountain, a mountain topped by two billboards that you can't see from the bottom.
How much do you increase your chance of catching the subway by walking to the nearest stop in the direction of travel? Where is the break-even point?
[Editor's note: The problem starts with an editing mistake, repeating section 045 (note) from earlier in this episode.]
There is a threshold point in-between two stations where it's faster to walk against the direction of travel. To calculate that point, Matt and Bec first walked between a few stations to measure their walking speed. The audio from that walk is part of the episode. During the walk, among other things, they wonder why police cars have different sirens. They also took the subway back and timed it.
On average, the subway is about 5.9 times faster than walking. While the average wait at the platform is approx. 2.5 minutes, it is independent of walking forwards and backwards. With this data, the threshold point is at 41.5% along the way between two stations, which Google Maps' path finding confirms.
A ding ding by Bec
How long is a New York Minute, really? People say it's the time between when a traffic light turns green and a driver starts to honk their horn. Is Lauren Armstrong-Carter the best producer of all time?
A New York Minute is a quick duration. Originally, it came from the suggestion that it takes a New Yorker a minute to do what it would take a Texan an hour to do, to suggest that New York is fast.
While in a bar, Bec and Matt stumbled across the movie New York Movie, which Bec and Matt watched and took notes on. Bec theorizes that one of the Olsen twins died, and the entire movie was acted by the other one. Matt thinks that they were never twins and there was always only one. Matt and Bec have recreated all the recognizable New York shots from the movie. The runtime of the film was 01:30:47, or 5437 seconds, or 90.61 times a normal minute.
There is no Any Other Business this episode, but Bec and Matt recorded one episode of the I'm a Wizard bonus podcast on their walk for problem 045-1. Matt was recognized live during the recording.
In this episode, one of the three patrons thanked was a repeat from a previous episode. They'll get a postcard from Bec.
Bec and Matt have forgotten to pick up twisties, but will rectify that for the next episode. Oh, and they got backstage access and hung out with Seth Meyers.
Bec flew home two days after the NY episode 045 was recorded. Bec gives a shoutout to the A Problem Squared fans at An Evening Of Unnecessary Detail.
While Matt was filming a video on pool, Bec was playing a lot of darts and was getting better and better. Afterwards, she played darts against Matt, Grant Sanderson, Rollie, and Genn, and didn't win.
Bec has started a podcast called Elon Musk vs Twitter, a few episodes of which are already out.
After New York, Matt and Alex stayed in the US and filmed two videos. On the last night they found a bar in Tallahassee that had a dart board. They first played some pool and then some darts. The dart board was a modern electronic one that does the maths for you, which eventually won Matt over.
Bec tells a cool Grant Sanderson darts anecdote.
Bec, bookshelves are kind of boring. What creative and different ways can I store my books? [Editor's note: More details follow.]
Matt's books are unsorted, except for the bookshelf in the background of his videos. Gavin (Bec's husband) sorts his books by height. Some people sort them by color. Bec has some large books, which go where they fit. She decorates her bookshelves with action figures and other knick knacks. She's always wanted a secret bookshelf door.
If you don't need immediate access to your books, you could stack them in arbitrary shapes, for example chairs or a bed. Matt wants to build a bookshelf out of books. Bec suggests book columns to frame doors. In a video, Matt used (and destroyed) copies of his own books as weights, and some people got mad. Bec talks about a business idea she had for book shelves that double as boxes for moving the books.
Awaiting ding from Sarah. Listeners are encouraged to send in pictures of their own ideas.
Usually, lottery maths videos are hung up on the likelihood to win the jackpot and don't go into detail about the chances of smaller consecutive winnings. If you were to buy a lottery ticket once a week for 30 years, what are the overall odds of coming out with a net positive, and how often would you need to win any of the smaller winnings?
Matt wrote a German lottery simulator. By the way, the optimized version of Matt's code from problem 038-1 is under half a millisecond now. After running the simulation, the average earning was 37.7% of the money spent by each person. 2.5% of people made a profit. In the UK, the average earning is fixed to 53%, while Germany's is set at 50%.
Matt wrote another simulator that follows a single person until they win the jackpot. They won the jackpot (12.5 million €) after about 5 million years. Along the way, they won 77.5 million € in smaller prizes. The tickets cost 305 million €.
In conclusion, if your plan is making money via the lottery, you won't.
Many people responded. One person was angry because they got the song stuck in their head. Bec requests a mashup of Semi-Charmed Life and Year 3000. One unnamed person wrote a very detailed answer that Bec and Matt will put up on socials. They looked into how long you can keep sperm frozen (55 years) and mentioned that no known submarine can go 88 miles per hour.
People have sent in made up word pairs, one of which Bec took and tweaked slightly. It consists of "vedpharkwing" (a bird that gets way too close for comfort) and "bumolscquytz" ("I've got a particularly bad case of bumolscquytz").
Ricard Broughton [Editor's note: May be misspelled] recommended to turn "veldcraft" into "veldcrafty" for one more letter. It's no bumolscquytz though.
Nosair [Editor's note: Spelling very likely incorrect] wanted to generate the longest English-sounding word with no repeating letters. They got "macrosuadingly", which is 15 letters long. However, actual English words matching those criteria exist: "dermatoglyphics" and "uncopyrightable".
Matt brought Cheetos Crunchy from America, which are supposedly made with real cheese. They're good, but not as salty as proper twisties. If you want to send snacks, email Bec.
During the US tour, Matt usually chose hotels near craft beer places. One of those was the largest beer garden of the world in Raleigh — according to the number of beers on tap, which is approximately 400.
Bec will be co-hosting Comic Con Brussels. She might be able to use her visit to measure some stairs for slinky action. She only has a short amount of time though. On Monday, she'll be on set for filming something that, so far, only patrons know about.
How many bees would it take to lift a person?
1.5 million for Matt, 1 million for Bec.
People have measured how much weight a bee can carry using two approaches, both of which involve attaching string to them. On average, a standard bee can lift (flying) 53% of its body weight.
According to research by the Queen Mary University of London and the University of Western Australia, it would only take 3 horned dung beetles to lift Bec, or 4 to lift Matt. Bec is skeptical, and can't ding this additional information. However, she does concede she could be lifted by 17 cats.
A ding, but not a dung(beetle)
I've heard that honey can't get bad over time. Is that true, and if it is, why? Subproblem: Also, are there other foods with basically infinite shelf life?
Marcos sent in a very similar problem.
Yes, it is true. Archaeologists have found 5000 year old jars of honey in Aegyptian tombs and it was still edible (though crystallized, but that's perfectly fine). However, the honey needs to stay sealed.
Honey is a sugar, and sugars are hygroscopic, which means they will suck in moisture if unsealed. It is also pretty acidic, which will kill of things that try to grow in it. Finally, bees have an enzyme in their stomach (glucose oxidase) that breaks down, among other things, into hydrogen peroxide, which will also kill off things. These factors mean that honey is also good for putting on wounds, apparently. If a pig ran into a beehive, you'd have honey roast ham.
There have been unconfirmed stories about (Russian) explorers taking bites out of mammoth corpses. Some paleontologists used the marrow of a 50'000 year old horse bone, and researchers ate meat from a 36'000 year old bison corpse. Fruit cake is also a candidate.
The "ding" of your microwave after heating your crystallized honey
There were lots of good suggestions. Bec's favourites were DJ Miss Heard Lyrics, DJ Jee Day, DJ Flipflop Anonymous, DJ Hilla Cool, DJ Spooky Waxwork Ghosttrain (Bec doesn't want context), Simon, DJ Beeside Flips, DJ Flip It, Flip It Real Good, and DJ Lil Sausage (and not a sausage more).
Ben loves the way the question was answered. They like butterflies as a symbol for hope. While a common symbol, it also references the butterfly effect, which Bec likes. Ben would love to commission an artist of Bec's choice to design such a symbol, as a gift to the podcast.
Someone else mentioned Jewish spiritualism, where you carry the phrases "I am dust and ashes" and "the whole world was made for me, only me" in your hands (in your mind). Bec suggests "yeah" and "nah", one on each wing of the butterfly.
The correct answer (which some people got), was Shya LaBeouf.
The podcast is almost at 900'000 downloads. Matt is underwhelmed because he views it from a YouTube perspective. Matt and Bec are looking for a way to celebrate 1'000'000 downloads (which Matt now interprets as similar to 1'000'000 subscribers on YouTube).
Someone gave Bec Fonzies from Italy, which Matt describes as anemic twisties that have been living in the UK for 17 years. Bec and Matt like them; they're the closest to twisties so far.